Skip to content
Latest Updates
“Allottee cannot be compelled to accept a belated offer of possession”: NCDRC directs builder to refund ₹1.26 crore with 9 per cent interest for delay in delivering flat in Nagpur project Post-decree deposit cannot retrospectively revive right to defend summary suit under Order 37 CPC: J&K and Ladakh HC Top Legal Developments [9-15 Nov 2026]: Digital Arrest Scams, GST, AI Deepfakes and More Law & Logic announces 1st Constitution Day Quiz Competition 2026; Registration open to law students nationwide Appreciating the scope and dimensions of “surcharge” in taxation laws: Implications of Supreme Court’s larger Bench exposition on “surcharge” and “cess” Justice Rajesh Bindal, former Supreme Court Judge assumes office as NCLAT Chairperson

Guj HC | Court directs transfer of winding-up proceedings to NCLT; scattering litigation to various forums leads to multiplicity, abuse of process of law

Content reader

Listen to this article

Ready to read this article aloud.
Guj HC | Court directs transfer of winding-up proceedings to NCLT; scattering litigation to various forums leads to multiplicity, abuse of process of law

Gujarat High Court: The Division Bench of Vineet Kothari and B.N. Karia, JJ., took up a petition which dealt with the parties not only filing Civil Suits, Writ Petitions, and Letters Patent Appeals under Article 226 of the Constitution but also going for forum shopping.

The Writ petition was dismissed by the order dated 06-10-2010. In Letters Patent Appeal, this Court had initially passed the status quo order on 13-12-2010 which came to be modified after detailed hearing on 17-02-2021.

The assets of the Defaulter Company –  GPPML were taken over by GSFC in the exercise of its statutory powers under Section 29 of the SFC Act, 1951 and sold away to SIL at a price which was the subject matter of challenge.

Detailed interim orders passed in the matter leading to the proposed order passed by the Court for facilitating the transfer of all the proceedings to the National Company Law Tribunal (NCLT), Ahmedabad, which is the expert fact-finding Tribunal constituted under the provisions of the New & Special Law viz. Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code, 2016 in terms of the decision of the Supreme Court in the case of Action Ispat and Power (P) Ltd. v. Shyam Metalics and Energy Ltd., (2021) 224 Comp Cases 35 (SC) where it was held that the winding up Court or the Company Court should transfer the winding up proceedings to NCLT, not only at the initial stage, but even in the mid stage of winding-up proceedings, unless the winding-up proceedings have reached a stage where it would be irreversible and making it impossible to set the clock back and then only that the Company Court must proceed with the winding-up, instead of transferring the proceedings to NCLT under IBC provision.

The Court noticed that the auction purchaser – SIL not only was involved in litigation before this Court, and entered into an alleged OTS (One Time Settlement) with GSFC which is with a doubtful integrity to say the least and is under a serious contest by left out Secured and Unsecured Creditors, but SIL also approached the Hon’ble Delhi High Court by way of writ petitions merely because it had a namesake registered office of the Company in Delhi also, whereas its industry in question is in Gujarat.

The Court stated that scattering the litigation in various Forums is the root cause of multiplicity of litigation and amounts to misuse and abuse of process of law and by sheer passing of the different orders which may or may not be conflicting orders inter-se by different Forums, who apparently would have the competent jurisdiction to be seized of those proceedings and passed those orders, ultimately may result in an utter messy confusion of the things and unresolved problems for long time. Such malpractices deserve to be seriously checked by enacting some kind of filters where the parties to one lis essentially are restricted to one competent Forum to avoid any such chance of conflicting orders and forum shopping.

The hurried One Time Settlement of GSFC with SIL in favour of which even the major part of the auction price was converted into a term loan by GSFC and in the repayment of which, SIL defaulted, still instead of again taking over the assets and re-auctioning them, GSFC chose, for the reasons best known to it to enter into One Time Settlement with SIL at a mere Rs.60 lakhs and that is a matter to be looked into by the NCLT. The said SIL is also said to have stopped its production activities and the assets of GPPML sold to it under Section 29 way back in the year 1990 are still in disuse or are not being used for any productive activity and that is not only a wastage of assets for the creditors and other stakeholders, but also a national waste.

The Court was of the view that NCLT would be the best suited Forum in these circumstances to the concerned and connected issues in this case.[Lalitaben Govindbhai Patel v. Gujarat State Financial Corpn., 2021 SCC OnLine Guj 1077, decided on 26-07-2021]


Suchita Shukla, Editorial Assistant has reported this brief.


Appearance:

For the Appellants: Mr Sandeep Singhi and Mr AS Vakil

For the Respondents: Mr BH Bhagat, Mr RD Dave, Mr Pranav G Desai, Mr Abhijit P Joshi, Mr Nandish Y Chudgar and Mr Devang D Trivedi

WhatsApp LinkedIn

0 replies

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *.

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.