SCC Weekly Public Accountability, Vigilance and Prevention of Corruption — Sting/Undercover Operations
Criminal liability of sting operation conducted by private person on being charged for having deployed means which themselves involve culpable act such as offering bribe to main offender is not obliterated merely because operation is claimed to be conducted in public interest as a journalistic exercise. Question would arise whether…
SCC Weekly Income Tax — Tax at Source/TDS — Refund
Cases Reported in 2014 SCC Vol. 6 July 14, 2014 Part 3 When collection is illegal, Revenue is obliged to refund such amount with interest as money so deposited is retained and enjoyed by it. Hence, resident/deductor who had deducted tax at source and deposited the same before remitting amounts…
SCC Weekly Constitution of India — Art. 310 — Doctrine of Pleasure
Cases Reported in 2014 SCC VOL. 6 JULY 14, 2014 PART 3 Termination whether based on material evidence, can be examined by Court, but not sufficiency of the grounds. Furthermore, there is no need of assignment/disclosure of reasons for invocation of pleasure doctrine. Lastly, Court cannot substitute its own conclusion…
SCC Weekly Environment Protection and Pollution Control — Encroachment/Diversion of/Intrusion into forest land
Cases Reported in 2014 SCC VOL. 6 July 7, 2014 Part 2 Use of 0.6556 ha of forest land falling in Kutch Desert Wildlife Sanctuary by BSF for construction of Repeater Station as recommended by Standing Committee of National Board for Wildlife, allowed subject to conditions. Use of 124.054 ha of…
SCC Weekly Criminal Trial — Witnesses — Child/Young witness
Evidence of a child witness must be subjected to close scrutiny to rule out possibility of tutoring. It can be relied upon, if court finds that child witness has sufficient intelligence and understanding of obligation of oath. As a matter of caution, court must find adequate corroboration to child witness’…
SCC Weekly Contempt of Court — Generally — Safeguarding Judicial System
In the matter of continuous wilful disobedience of court orders, there is essential need of an iron hand to enforce rule of law, punish contemnors and maintain faith and confidence of people in the judiciary. Non-compliance with judicial orders shakes the very foundation of judicial system and undermines the rule…
SCC Weekly Constitution of India — Art. 21 — Right to Reputation
Right to reputation is an inseparable facet of Art. 21. Recording of disparaging remarks by Single Judge which were affirmed by Division Bench of High Court against appellant Chief Minister which were unnecessary to adjudicate upon issues, visiting him with adverse consequences in proceedings where he was not impleaded as…
SCC Weekly Courts, Tribunals and Judiciary — Role of Judiciary — Duty of Superior Courts
Superior courts should not pass caustic remarks on subordinate courts unless facts disclose designed effort to frustrate cause of justice with mala fide intention. Bona fide errors should not invite disparaging remarks. Judges do commit errors which are to be corrected by superior courts. Superior courts can convey their anxiety…
SCC Weekly Constitution of India — Arts. 21, 14, 32, 142 and 136 — Communal riots —...
In light of various steps taken by State Government for rehabilitation, protection and other preventive measures, facts and figures, statistics supported by materials, there is no need to either constitute SIT (Special Investigation Team) or entrust investigation to CBI at this juncture. Special Investigation Cell (SIC) constituted by State Government…




