SCC Weekly Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 — Ss. 34 and 5 — Merits of arbitral award
None of the grounds contained in S. 34(2)(a) deal with the merits of the decision rendered by an arbitral award, it is only when arbitral award is in conflict with public policy of India as per S. 34(2)(b)(ii), that merits of an arbitral award are to be looked into under…
SCC Weekly Illegal immigrants from Bangladesh in Assam
Constitution of India — Arts. 32, 21, 29, 14, 10, 11 and 4(2) r/w Arts. 368(1), 325, 326, 355 and 145(3) — Illegal immigrants from Bangladesh in Assam: Challenge to S. 6-A, Citizenship Act, 1955 after a delay of 27 yrs (said section inserted in 1985), is maintainable. When it…
SCC Weekly Civil Procedure Code, 1908 — Order of dismissal of counterclaim when constitutes decree
Civil Procedure Code, 1908 — Or. 8 R. 6-A, Or. 2 R. 2 and S. 2(2) — Order of dismissal of counterclaim when constitutes decree: Counterclaim when conclusively adjudicated on merits and dismissed by order of court, finality is attached in respect of rights of defendant, such order of dismissal…
SCC Weekly Constitution of India — Art. 226 — Writs — Mandamus
Interference with policy decision on ground that it is ultra vires/arbitrary/invalid, etc., and, issuance of mandamus to frame policy in particular manner are absolutely different. Issue of mandamus commanding appellant to carry out census in particular manner is not permissible. Courts have jurisdiction to declare law unconstitutional where called for,…
SCC Weekly Constitution of India — Art. 141 — Binding effect of rulings of Supreme Court
When a higher court has rendered a particular decision, said decision must be followed by a subordinate or lower court unless it is distinguished or overruled or set aside. If litigants or lawyers are permitted to argue that something that was correct, but was not argued earlier before a higher…
SCC Weekly 2014 SCC Vol. 9 October 21, 2014 Part 1
Constitution of India — Arts. 75(1); & 164(1); and 32 — Appointment of Council of Ministers (Union or State) “Advice” under Arts. 75(1); and 164(1); means formation of opinion by PM/CM and it is in their wisdom to choose any person for appointment as Minister of Council of Ministers. Said formation…
SCC Weekly Cases Reported in 2014 SCC Vol. 8 September 21, 2014 Part 2
Constitution of India — Art. 14 — Underclassification Inclusion of all under-18s into a class called “juveniles” under Juvenile Justice (Care and Protection of Children) Act, 2000 is valid as it provides a separate scheme of investigation, trial and punishment for offences committed by them. A class of persons is…
SCC Weekly Hindu Marriage Act, 1955 — S. 13(1)(i-b) — Desertion —Inference of
For the offence of desertion so far as the deserting spouse is concerned, two essential conditions must be there (1) the factum of separation, and (2) the intention to bring cohabitation permanently to an end (animus deserendi). Similarly two elements are essential so far as the deserted spouse is concerned:…
SCC Weekly Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 — Pt. I or Pt. II — Doctrine of severability
Law of substantive contract does not determine law of arbitration agreement/lex arbitri. Parties are entitled to agree that law of one country would govern substantive contract and laws of another country would apply to arbitration agreement. Parties can also agree that conduct of reference to arbitration would be governed by…




