Delhi High Court: While considering a petition seeking directions for examination and certification of the teaser, trailer and promotional material of the film “Suryaa: Ant Se Aarambh Tak” by the Central Board of Film Certification (CBFC), and removal of the impugned teaser on the ground that it projected doctors in a defamatory manner and could incite violence against healthcare workers, a Single Judge Bench of Amit Mahajan, J., disposed of the petition, taking note of the undertaking given by Respondent 4 to carry an appropriate disclaimer in the trailer as well as in the film, stating that the movie was a work of fiction and an adaptation of the original Malayalam movie “Joseph”. The Court observed that the original Malayalam movie had not been banned by any authority and, considering the undertaking given by Respondent 4, held that no further orders were required to be passed in the present petition.
Background
The petitioner had filed the present petition seeking directions to Respondents 1 and 2 to exercise their powers under Sections 4, 5-B and 7-C, Cinematograph Act, 1952, read with the Third Schedule to Cinematograph (Certification) Rules, 2024, and require Respondents 4 and 5 to place the impugned teaser and all other teasers, trailers and promotional material of the film “Suryaa: Ant Se Aarambh Tak” before the CBFC for examination and certification.
The petitioner had contended that the impugned teaser, in its present form, was against public order and incited the commission of cognizable offences against doctors employed in private and corporate hospitals. Accordingly, the petitioner had sought directions to Respondent 3 to take down, block or disable access to the impugned teaser under Section 69-A, Information Technology Act, 2000, read with Rule 3(1)(d), Information Technology (Intermediary Guidelines and Digital Media Ethics Code) Rules, 2021.
The petitioner had further sought directions to Respondents 1 and 2 to examine the film and all its teasers, trailers and promotional material in accordance with Section 5-B(1), Cinematograph Act, and the 2026 Guidelines, and to require necessary excisions and modifications. It was also prayed that the film and its promotional material carry a disclaimer stating that the film was a work of fiction, was not based on true events, and that violence against doctors and healthcare workers was a punishable offence.
Additionally, the petitioner had sought directions to Respondent 1 to exercise its powers under the Cinematograph Act, 1952, in respect of teasers, trailers and promotional material of films published on the internet, and to prescribe the internet as a medium for exhibition of films under Sections 4(3) and 8(2)(cb) of the Act, to the extent necessary. The petitioner had also sought issuance of guidelines under Section 5-B (2), requiring such online promotional material to be examined by the CBFC before publication.
The Court had issued notice in the matter. The Central Government Standing Counsel had accepted notice on behalf of the Union of India, while notice had been directed to be served upon the remaining respondents through all permissible modes. The respondents had been granted liberty to file their replies before the next date of hearing, and the matter had been listed for 16 November 2026.
Analysis
The Court noted that the present matter had been listed on 17 November 2026, on account of the declaration of a holiday on 16 November 2026, pursuant to notification dated 11 November 2026. The Court observed that the petitioners were practising doctors who apprehended that the trailer of the subject film projected doctors in a manner which was defamatory. It was the petitioners’ case that such incorrect projection of doctors had also led to incidents of violence against frontline healthcare workers in some parts of the country.
The petitioners submitted that doctors, in any case, faced attacks from disgruntled family members of patients and that films projecting doctors in a bad light further created an atmosphere detrimental to frontline healthcare workers. The petitioners were also aggrieved that the representations made by them to the authorities concerned had not been addressed.
On the other hand, Respondent 4 submitted that the subject movie was a remake of the original Malayalam movie “Joseph”, which had undisputedly never been banned by the respondent authorities and had also won several national and international awards. It was further submitted that the apprehension raised by the petitioners was misplaced. Respondent 4, on instructions, undertook to put an adequate disclaimer in the trailer as well as in the film, stating that the movie was a work of fiction and an adaptation of the original Malayalam movie “Joseph”.
Considering that the subject movie was undisputedly a remake of the Malayalam movie “Joseph”, which had already been released and had not been banned by any authority, and also taking into account the undertaking given on behalf of Respondent 4 to put an appropriate disclaimer in the trailer as well as in the film, the Court was of the opinion that no orders were required to be passed in the present petition.
The Court also took note of the submission made by Respondent 1 that no permission had been granted to the film at that stage. However, the Court clarified that the petition was being disposed of only in view of the apprehension raised by the petitioners and the undertaking given on behalf of Respondent 4 that an appropriate disclaimer would be carried in the trailer as well as in the film, stating that the movie was a work of fiction and was only an adaptation of the original Malayalam movie “Joseph”.
Decision
Accordingly, the Delhi High Court disposed of the petition in terms of the undertaking recorded on behalf of Respondent 4.
[Dr Nishant Soni v. Union of India, W.P.(C) 16253 of 2026, decided on 17-11-2026]
Advocates who appeared in this case:
For the Petitioner: Varun Singh, Parajat, Arushi Vig, Ashhab Khan, Urvashi Chauhan and Kajal Gupta, Advocates
For the Respondent: Jagdish Chandra, CGSC with Keshav Pawar, GP and Aishwarya Sinha, Maanya Saxena, Sanskriti Sharma, Vinita Solanki, Advocates for R-1, 2 & 3 with Rajiv Nayar, Sr. Adv., Vedanta Verma, Ashok Sarogi, Sunil and Vibhor Kush, Advocates for R-4.





0 replies