Skip to content
Latest Updates
Delhi notifies Rules for online filing, tracking and appeals in time-bound delivery of citizen services Call for Papers | MNLU, Chhatrapati Sambhajinagar invites submissions for Volume V MNLU-CS Student Law Review Supreme Court to Establish Permanent Committee on Disability Rights; CJI Surya Kant Directs SCLSC to Set Up Panels of Lawyers and Sign Language Interpreters “Legislature cannot nullify a judgment by enacting law without removing the basis”: Andhra Pradesh High Court strikes down Section 147-A, Income-tax Act, 1961 as unconstitutional ICA and RICS to host Conclave on “Mediation in Transition: Institutional Trust, Professional Standards and the Age of Artificial Intelligence” Cyril Amarchand Mangaldas advises the Placement Agents on INR 3,500 crore QIP by Aegis Logistics Limited

Assessee’s income for tax assessment cannot be clubbed with minor daughter’s share of sale proceeds, deposited as per Court’s order: ITAT

The assessee deposited 50% minor daughter’s share in the nationalized bank. Further, the assessee accounted his 50% share and offered the same as capital gain with the deduction of claim under Section 54 of the Income Tax Act, 1961.

Content reader

Listen to this article

Ready to read this article aloud.
Assessee’s income for tax assessment cannot be clubbed with minor daughter’s share of sale proceeds, deposited as per Court’s order: ITAT

Income Tax Appellate Tribunal: In the present appeal against the order of Commissioner of Income Tax (Appeals) (‘Commissioner’), whereby the Assessing Officer’s decision to club the income arising from the share of assessee’s minor daughter’s with the assessee’s income was upheld, S.S. Viswanethra Ravi, Judicial Member, allowed the appeal and stated that the assessee could not decide the utilization of his minor daughter’s share of sale proceeds, as it was deposited as per Court’s order and it is impossible to club the same with the assessee’s income. The Tribunal stated that the addition made in the income of the assessee with reference to assessee’s minor daughter’s share was not justified and thus, it was deleted. The Tribunal also deleted the disallowance of brokerage expenses, recognizing the standard industry practice and accepting the assessee’s explanation.

Background:

In the matter in hand, the assessee, inherited a property jointly with his minor daughter through his spouse after her death. The assessee sold the said property with the permission of City Civil Court, Chennai and as per direction, deposited 50% minor daughter’s share in the nationalized bank, that cannot be used until she attains majority, in the name of the Registrar, City Civil Court.

The assessee filed return of income declaring his total income, in response to the notice under section 148 of the Income Tax Act, 1961 (‘the Act’). The Assessing Officer asked the assessee to furnish details in support of the deduction claimed in the return of income. The Assessing Officer stated that the assessee had not declared income of his minor daughter on the received sale consideration. The assessee stated that he accounted his 50% share in the capital gains and claimed deduction under Section 54 of the Act by filing valuation report given by the Chartered Engineer and registered valuer. However, the Assessing Officer assessed that the income arising from the daughter’s share must be clubbed with the assessee’s income and accordingly made additions to the assessee’s total income.

The Assessing Officer determined capital gains with reference to assessee’s minor daughter’s share at 50% by giving benefit under section 54 of the Act only with reference to assessee’s share. The Commissioner upheld the additions to the assessee’s total income and thus, aggrieved by the same, present appeal has been filed.

Analysis, Law, and Decision:

The Tribunal observed that the only issue in the present case, was whether the assessee should have included the share of assessee’s minor daughter also in his income in offering long term capital gain. Admittedly, the said 50% share of assessee’s minor daughter was deposited in the name of Registrar, City Civil Court, Chennai under section 8(2) of Hindu Minority and Guardianship Act, 1956, the receipt of which reflected in the impugned order.

The Tribunal noted that on perusal of the order of the City Civil Court, Chennai, the assessee filed a petition seeking the Court’s permission to alienate property standing in the name of his deceased wife, to facilitate better education and welfare of their minor daughter. Considering the same, the City Civil Court permitted the assessee to sell his minor daughter’s interest in the property and deposit her share in any of the nationalized bank in the name of Registrar, City Civil Court.

The Tribunal stated that the assessee could not decide the utilization of his minor daughter’s share as it was deposited as per Court’s order and it is impossible to club the same with the assessee’s income. Therefore, the addition made in the hands of the assessee with reference to assessee’s minor daughter’s share was not justified and thus, it is deleted. Further regarding the brokerage charges, which is of 1% of the sale consideration, as it is usual practice across real estate sector, the Tribunal disallowed it for want of evidence, and thus, it is also deleted.

[Pradeep Jeyavelu v. CIT, 2025 SCC OnLine ITAT 9828, decided on 3-9-2025]


Advocates who appeared in this case:

For the Appellant: R.S. Hithesh, Advocate

For the Respondent: V. Aswathy, JCIT

WhatsApp LinkedIn

0 replies

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *.

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.