High Courts Archives

‘Immunity granted under S.35 of Maharashtra Village Panchayats Act, 1959 is for post and not person’; Bombay HC sets aside notice of no confidence motion against woman sarpanch

The Sarpanch is a post conferred upon a person and therefore, the term ‘Sarpanch’ as well as the post of Sarpanch cannot be distinguished as both have identical meanings in common parlance.

Case Briefs High Courts

‘Casual approach unmindful of law of limitation’; Delhi HC denies condonation of delay to Railways in appeal against compensation of Rs 6 Lakhs

“Consideration to condone can be made only if there is a reasonable explanation and the condonation cannot be merely because the appellant is a Government body where procedural and bureaucratic delays are well known.”

Case Briefs High Courts

‘No difference if law graduate candidate not enrolled’; Chhattisgarh HC allows candidates without Bar Enrollment to appear in Civil Judge Exam

“In a selection process, the scope of the candidates for participation should not be narrowed down by imposing unwarranted conditions rather more candidates should be allowed to participate so that better qualified candidates may be selected.”

Case Briefs High Courts

Delhi High Court rejects anticipatory bail to wife accused of inflicting severe burns on husband with boiling water and red chilli powder

Men who are victims of violence at the hands of their wives often face unique difficulties, including societal disbelief and the stigma associated with being perceived as a victim. Such stereotypes perpetuate the erroneous belief that men cannot suffer violence in domestic relationships.

Case Briefs High Courts

Delhi HC grants bail to four co-owners of coaching centre basement in flooding case leading to death of three civil services aspirants

The Court directed the applicants (‘accused persons’) to make their voluntary donation of Rs. 5 lakhs with Delhi State Legal Services Authority (‘DSLSA’), within two weeks, towards the welfare of the families of the deceased. The member secretary, DSLSA, shall then consider the claims from the families of deceased and issue direction for disbursal of the said amount after due consideration.

Case Briefs High Courts

‘Principles of natural justice thrown to the winds’; Bombay HC stays license suspension order of female advocate for alleged misconduct

A party to the proceedings being not informed of the jurisdictional authority which decides the complaint itself is fatal to all norms of fairness.

Case Briefs High Courts

‘Merely smoking is no ground to conclude that victim is of deviant character’; Kerala HC upholds conviction u/s 377 IPC

“Youngsters are prone to commit mistakes/follies during their teens or young age for which they cannot be branded as deviant and wholly unreliable.”

Case Briefs High Courts

Bombay HC grants bail to IIM graduate for drunk driving; directs community service holding a ‘Don’t Drink and Drive’ banner

The accused, a 32-year-old MBA graduate from Indian Institute of Management, Lucknow, was incarcerated for almost two months for drunk driving, violating check posts and damaging police barricades.

Case Briefs High Courts

Rule 11(1)(v) of Rajasthan Parole Rules recognises wife’s impending delivery as valid ground for emergent parole: Rajasthan High Court

“Without any justified reason, the application filed by the petitioner has not been decided by the District Magistrate/ District Committee. Aforesaid act of the authorities is not in consonance with the mandatory provisions contained under Rule 23 of the Rule of 2021.”

Case Briefs High Courts

Punjab and Haryana HC denies relief under Section 21 of Extradition Act to alleged gangster Sukhpreet Budha

The Court held that he was not aided by Section 21 since he was not extradited by the Union of India from Armenia but instead came of his own volition.

Case Briefs High Courts

‘No other evidence except victim’s bare words’; Bombay HC acquits father for allegedly having sexual intercourse with daughter

“It was suggested that the victim girl lodged a false report against her father because the father did not give green signal to her marriage with the boy to whom she wanted to marry.”

Case Briefs High Courts

Bombay HC rejects plea to stay release of film “Sky Force” in copyright infringement case against script titled “Fire Bird”

The proceedings in the present case are not only delayed but can be treated as litigation strategy on applicant’s part to claim urgent circulation and to seek ad-interim reliefs at the eleventh hour when the film is about to be released.

Case Briefs High Courts

Consent to engage in physical relations does not extend to misuse of a person’s private moments in an inappropriate manner: Delhi High Court

The assertion made in the bail application that the complainant, “being a married woman, was mature and intelligent enough to understand the significance and consequences of her actions” is a specious argument that cannot absolve the accused of the allegations levelled against him.

Case Briefs High Courts

‘Granting appointment out of turn would violate fairness & equality’; Bombay HC dismisses plea for compassionate appointment to waitlisted candidate

“The object of compassionate appointment is to relieve the hardship due to the death of a bread winner in the family and the appointment is provided to redeem the family in distress. At the same time, it is to be borne in mind that compassionate appointment cannot be construed as opening an alternative mode of recruitment to public employment.”

Case Briefs High Courts

Punjab and Haryana HC orders reinstatement of a Judge dispensed with service after complaint by his former wife

The Court noted that the report of Administrative Judge with regard to work and conduct of the petitioner was also without granting him an opportunity of being heard.

Case Briefs High Courts

Bail proceedings relate only to the release of a person from ‘judicial custody’ and cannot be employed to seek release from ‘executive detention’: Delhi High Court

The anomaly is that if a foreign national is released from judicial custody on bail while facing charges under Foreigners Act, how can the same foreign national be detained again at a detention centre/restriction centre by executive order for violation of the very same provisions.

Case Briefs High Courts

Bombay HC dismisses plea for postponement of 38th National Games due to denied entry to Maharashtra Women Diving Team for alleged biased & unfair selection trials

Bombay High Court suggested State to seek extension for the entry of Maharashtra Women Diving Team since fresh trials were soon to be conducted.

Case Briefs High Courts

Considerations for bail cannot be same in cases involving anti-national activities, terrorism and involvement with dreaded gangsters: Delhi HC dismisses bail petition of UAPA accused

“This Court while acknowledging that speedy trial is necessary as a Constitutional prescription, observes that in cases involving anti-national activities and terrorism on an international scale, long incarceration in itself ought not to lead to enlargement on bail, when facts showed involvement in such activities which can have a national and transnational impact.”

Case Briefs High Courts

“Necessity for gender-neutral society”; Karnataka HC dismisses plea to transfer divorce petition on account of husband’s greater inconvenience

“Women are the primary victims in most situations, but that does not mean that men are not affected by the cruelty of women. Therefore, there is necessity for a gender-neutral society”.

Case Briefs High Courts

“Gaps in structure attributed to seasonal changes”; MP High Court dismisses plea alleging cracks in newly constructed Flyover

“Since no research or scientific report has been placed by the petitioner to support the claims, we are not inclined to entertain the present petition.”