Apoorva, Author at SCC Times

Supreme Court upholds consumers’ right to peaceful protest; Quashes defamation complaint filed by developer against homebuyers

“Homebuyers and developers have not always been the best of friends. Instances are innumerable where the two have been at daggers drawn. This case presents one such instance”

Case Briefs High Courts

Runaway couples must learn to face society, cannot claim security as a matter of course or right: Allahabad High Court

“In a deserving case, the Court can provide security to the couple but cannot lend them the support they have sought. They have to learn to support each other and face society.”

Case Briefs Supreme Court

Supreme Court resolves complexities of Section 15(2) of the Copyright Act with a two-pronged approach for design protection

In the present case, the Supreme Court examined the vagaries of IP law and the intrinsic synergy that exists between two independent legislations, namely the Designs Act and the Copyright Act.

Case Briefs Supreme Court

‘Eligibility criteria declared by fresh advertisement cannot be changed midway through recruitment process’; Supreme Court upholds reservation of DSP post for SC Sports (Women)

“Once it is accepted that the DSP post in question was reserved for ‘SC Sports (Women)’ as per advertisement, the appellant must be accepted as the only person qualified in her category who could be appointed. This is because she is the only SC woman candidate who successfully cleared all the tests for the post of DSP.”

Case Briefs High Courts

[Karuvannur Bank Scam] Kerala High Court cautions police to ensure fair and unbiased investigation, free from political influence

“This court, therefore, hopes and trusts that the investigating officer will carry out the investigation in a proper and fair manner as expected from him being the officer of the police force.”

Case Briefs High Courts

‘Adult parents are entitled to live together, even without formal marriage’: Allahabad HC grants police protection to interfaith live-in couple amid threats

The couple also informed the Court that the police authorities were unwilling to register a FIR against the private respondents. They further stated that every time they approached the police station to lodge the FIR, they were subjected to humiliation and denied assistance.

Case Briefs High Courts

Kerala High Court grants 15 days parole to businessman Mohammed Nisham, serving life sentence in security guard murder case

“Even those undergoing imprisonment must be allowed to breathe the air of freedom, albeit briefly, provided they have exhibited consistently good conduct during incarceration and demonstrated a genuine inclination towards reformation and reintegration”

Case Briefs High Courts

‘Amendment of charges post witness examination should not lead to de novo trial’; Allahabad HC upholds conviction of seven men in honour killing case

Allahabad High Court said that the deposition of the informant, recorded during his examination-in-chief and cross-examination prior to the amendment of charges, could not be discarded merely because of his subsequent statements made during the later examination-in-chief conducted after the inclusion of Sections 504 and 506 IPC.

Case Briefs High Courts

Madras High Court allows Indu Makkal Katchi members to garland Dr. B.R. Ambedkar statue on his 135th Birth Anniversary, subject to conditions

The petitioner was entitled to be granted permission as prayed for, as he had submitted an affidavit of undertaking, wherein he had agreed to abide by any conditions that might be imposed by the respondents, particularly the police, in connection with the event.

Case Briefs Supreme Court

“Consensual relationships, where possibility of marriage may exist, cannot be given a colour of false pretext to marry after fall out”; SC quashes rape case against former judge

“The incident is of the year 2014 and any further litigation, will only prolong the suffering of both the parties, who are living their own separate lives”

Case Briefs Supreme Court

Supreme Court issues notice in challenge to Punjab & Haryana High Court’s decision on EWS reservation in PPSC Agriculture Development Officer recruitment

Punjab & Haryana HC in the impugned judgment clarified that EWS candidates who are selected based on merit and not on account of reservation, are not to be counted towards the quota meant for reservation.

Case Briefs High Courts

District Judge, not District Magistrate, has jurisdiction under S. 16(3) of Telegraph Act to adjudicate adequacy and sufficiency of compensation: Allahabad HC reiterates

“The Writ Court cannot substitute its wisdom with the policy making authorities unless it suffers from conditional infirmity. In view of the above, the present writ petition, which primarily seeks judicial intervention in a policy matter, does not warrant the Court’s indulgence at this stage.”

West Bengal SSC teacher recruitment scam

Case Briefs

Know why Supreme Court upheld Calcutta High Court’s decision to cancel entire West Bengal SSC teacher recruitment process of 2016

“Despite the factual background and the credible evidence indicating irregularities, WBSSC initially did try and cover up the lapses and illegalities. The cover up itself has made the verification and ascertainment more difficult or rather impossible given the scale of camouflage and dressing up done at each stage. We are convinced that the entire selection process was intentionally compromised due to the illegalities involved.”

Case Briefs Supreme Court

Candidate without minimum qualifications prescribed by expert body not entitled to appointment or promotion in educational institutions: Supreme Court

“The teachers who failed to acquire a Ph.D. within seven years as required, cannot be designated as Associate Professors nor be entitled to the higher pay scale.”

Case Briefs High Courts

Co-opted bar council members entitled to equal rights and privileges; cannot be treated as separate class from elected members: Kerala High Court

“The term “elected members” in the resolution shall also include the petitioners. As a result, the petitioners were entitled to all the rights and privileges accorded to the elected members of the Bar Council of Kerala as outlined in the resolution.”

Case Briefs High Courts

“Inconceivable that entire proceedings could have been concluded fairly within two weeks”: Madras HC upholds order quashing disciplinary action against Canara Bank employee

“A disciplinary proceeding should not resemble a point-to-point bullet train journey. A charge memo need not necessarily culminate in punishment.”

Case Briefs High Courts

No invalidation to one-year LLM degree for appointment in Public Departments or Universities: Madras High Court

“Even though the employer is a rightful person who should demand the educational requirement for a post to be filled up in this regard, the qualification contemplated by the employer shall not make any arbitrary discrimination between equivalent and similar course without any valid basis.”

Case Briefs High Courts

Madras High Court directs revaluation of law student’s criminology paper; Asks Ambedkar University to propose evaluation criteria and weightage

The University was directed to propose relevant criteria and weightage for evaluating answer scripts, ensuring a more rational and transparent assessment process.

Case Briefs High Courts

UGC Regulations on teachers’ appointments infringe Article 30 of the Constitution; not applicable to Minority Institutions: Madras High Court

“The Judiciary must recognize its pivotal role in restoring confidence among minorities, acting as a guardian of the rights that were pledged to them, thus reinforcing the very essence of India’s democratic ethos and its dedication to unity in diversity.”

Hot Off The Press News

Supreme Court stays tree felling in Telangana’s Kancha Gachibowli forest; Directs High Court Registrar to inspect and submit report

On 2-04-2025, the Telangana High Court had passed a stay on the tree felling in the area