Calcutta High Court: In an appeal by the State of Mizoram challenging the Single Judge’s order that set aside the cancellation of an e-tender for the sale of government land in Ballygunge, Kolkata, the Division Bench of Arijit Banerjee* and Apurba Sinha Ray, JJ., dismissed the appeal and held that the State had failed to show any overwhelming public interest justifying cancellation and described the decision as “a clear case of regime revenge”.
Background
The land at 24, Ashutosh Chowdhury Avenue, Ballygunge, Kolkata-700 019, was purchased by the Government of Mizoram in 1973. A guest house built on it served as Mizoram House in Kolkata until 1998, and the State’s Kolkata offices functioned from there. The old structure was demolished in 2020 to build a new Mizoram House, and the building plan was sanctioned in 2022.
In May 2023, the General Administration Department (GAD) floated an e-tender-cum-e-auction to sell the land instead. Excel Vincom Private Limited emerged as the highest bidder, and a Letter of Intent was issued on 4 August 2023. An unregistered agreement for sale was executed on 6 October 2023. The company paid the entire consideration of ₹38,29,91,994 (after deducting TDS) along with penal interest for delayed payment of the second instalment. The State accepted the payments without reservation.
The elections to the Mizoram Legislative Assembly were announced in October 2023, and the new Government took charge on 8 December 2023. By a letter of 21 December 2023, GAD told the company that the sale process would be delayed because of the elections and the festive season and that it hoped to proceed in January 2024. Meanwhile, Kolkata Mizo Students and the Calcutta Mizo Welfare Association had written to the Chief Minister on 22 December 2023 and 27 December 2023, urging that the sale be stopped because of the property’s sentimental and heritage value to the Mizo community.
On 4 January 2024, GAD cancelled the tender under Clause 3.1.11 read with Clauses 5.5 and 6.2 of the bid document, citing the “general interest of the public”, and stated that all amounts paid, including the earnest money, would be refunded. Excel Vincom challenged this by way of WPA No. 1344 of 2024. On 2 April 2024, the Single Judge allowed the petition, set aside the cancellation and directed the State to execute the sale deed within 6 weeks. The State appealed.
Also read: Even non-payment of entire sale consideration cannot be a ground cancellation of sale deed: SC
Analysis and Held
On maintainability, the Court held that the State’s cited decisions concerned statutory alternative remedies, which were not available here. An arbitration clause in the agreement for sale “did not and could not denude the High Court of its high prerogative writ jurisdiction”. The Court said that a civil suit, being a long drawn-out process, can hardly be called an efficacious alternative remedy.
Relying on Whirlpool Corpn. v. Registrar of Trade Marks, (1998) 8 SCC 1, ABL International Ltd. v. Export Credit Guarantee Corpn. of India Ltd., (2004) 3 SCC 553, Maharashtra Chess Assn. v. Union of India, (2020) 13 SCC 285 and Unitech Ltd. v. Telangana State Industrial Infrastructure Corpn., (2021) 16 SCC 35, the Court held that an alternative remedy does not oust Article 226 jurisdiction and that the matter lies in the court’s discretion, which the Single Judge had exercised properly.
The Bench rejected the argument that the writ court had in effect granted specific performance. Relying on Gujarat State Financial Corpn. v. Lotus Hotels (P) Ltd., (1983) 3 SCC 379, it held that an Article 12 authority cannot be allowed to resile from a solemn undertaking, and that a writ court can issue a mandamus to honour it. The Bench added that once the State is a party to a contract, it must act fairly, justly and reasonably under Article 14.
The Court stated in the present case, the Single Judge found the impugned act of the appellant to be arbitrary and illegal. The Judge has quashed such act i.e., the impugned letter of cancellation of tender and has issued a mandamus directing the appellant to complete the sale of the subject property in favour of the Respondent 1. We do not find anything wrong with such exercise of discretion by the Judge.
On the merits, the Court accepted that title passes only on registration of a deed of conveyance. But that did not mean a vendor could go back on a promise to sell recorded in a duly executed agreement “at his own sweet will”, since that would be a breach of contract and would make commercial deals “completely uncertain”. As for the cancellation clauses in the tender document, the Court said that the State was “putting the appellants’ case too high”. The right to cancel could not be exercised arbitrarily, unfairly or unreasonably.
The Court rejected the argument that estoppel does not apply to governmental acts, noting that promissory estoppel would estop an Article 12 authority from backing out of a solemn promise, and that the Government must show how public interest overrides the need to enforce the contract.
The Court found that great pains had been taken by both sides to finalise the deal, the entire consideration had been accepted without protest, and all formalities were complete. Only the conveyance remained, and its execution had been deferred only because of the elections. Once the ruling party changed, the Government “performed a complete volta face”. The State had to show public interest that was “overwhelming and demonstrable”, and it had not done so. The two representations from Mizo community groups did not show such an interest.
On the contention that Rule 309 of GFR, 2017 was not followed by the Government while taking a decision to sell the subject property, the Court held that whether the Government followed its own financial rules is an internal matter. A third party dealing with the Government may proceed on the footing that official acts have been regularly performed, as provided in Section 114, Illustration (e), Evidence Act, 1872. Relying on City & Industrial Development Corpn. of Maharashtra Ltd. v. Shishir Realty (P) Ltd., (2022) 16 SCC 527, the Court said the Government cannot renege on a promise acted upon by a citizen merely because of a change in regime. It reiterated that when the Government seeks to be excused from enforcing a promise, it must place before the court material showing how public interest overrides the need to enforce the contract.
The Court also noted that the State had not claimed that the property was sold below market value or that the exchequer would suffer, and so no prejudice would be caused by holding the State to its bargain. It distinguished the remaining authorities cited by the State, including Dresser Rand SA v. Bindal Agro Chem Ltd., (2006) 1 SCC 751 and Haryana Urban Development Authority v. Orchid Infrastructure Developers (P) Ltd., (2017) 4 SCC 243, noting that those cases involved only letters of intent or bids, whereas here a binding agreement had been executed. It also found Renaissance Distilleries & Breweries Ltd. v. State (NCT of Delhi), 2007 SCC OnLine Del 1134 inapplicable, since the writ petitioners wanted the tender process carried to its conclusion rather than challenging it.
On the 2 letters that constitute the fulcrum of the appellant’s case of extreme public interest warranting cancellation, the Court expressed “two representations do not demonstrate any such overwhelming public interest as would be a justification for cancelling the entire tender process which was on the verge of being carried to its logical conclusion. We agree with the Single Judge that cancellation of the tender process was an arbitrary act on the part of the appellant. Execution of the agreement for sale and payment of the entire consideration money by the writ petitioners, created in their favour, at least in equity, a right of having the property in question conveyed to them. The appellant came under a corresponding obligation. The only way the appellant could wriggle out of such contractual obligation was by establishing overwhelming public interest. It has failed to do so”.
Decision
Thus, the Court held that the State acted in an “unfair, unjust, arbitrary” manner that was “flagrantly violative” of Article 14, and that the cancellation was a clear case of regime revenge. It dismissed the appeal with no order as to costs and extended the time for the State to carry out the Single Judge’s order by 8 weeks from the date of judgment.
[State of Mizoram v. Excel Vincom (P) Ltd., FMA 772 of 2024, decided on 13-11-2026]
*Judgment authored by: Justice Arijit Banerjee
Advocates who appeared in this case :
For the Appellants: Biswajit Deb, Advocate General, Mizoram; Sayan Dev Kumar, Priyakshi Banerjee, Sourav Ghosh, Priyanka Ghosh, Advocates.
For the Respondents: S.N. Mookherjee, Senior Advocate; Rajarshi Dutta, Shaunak Mukhopadhyay, Shubrajyoti Mukherjee, Neelesh Choudhury, Anuradha Poddar, Advocates.





0 replies