Skip to content

Negative Phenolphthalein Test does not help accused when bribe money is placed at his direction: Kerala HC

The Court stated that a court may draw a presumption regarding the demand, acceptance or obtainment of illegal gratification only after the foundational facts have been established through relevant oral and documentary evidence, and not in the absence of such proof.

Content reader

Listen to this article

Ready to read this article aloud.
Negative Phenolphthalein Test does not help accused when bribe money is placed at his direction: Kerala HC

Kerala High Court: The present appeal was filed against the judgment of the Enquiry Commissioner and Special Judge, Kottayam, convicting the appellant, a former Assistant Engineer of Arakulam Gram Panchayat, for offences relating to demand and acceptance of illegal gratification under Sections 7 and 13(1)(d) read with Section 13(2) of the Prevention of Corruption Act, 1988 (PC Act). A Single Judge Bench of A. Badharudeen, J., upheld the conviction but reduced the sentence to the minimum permissible term. The Court held that the negative phenolpthalein test on the appellant’s hands did not, by itself, discredit the prosecution’s case, particularly when the tainted money had been placed inside the measurement book (M-book) at the appellant’s direction. Reiterating the principle that demand and acceptance of illegal gratification can be established through oral, documentary or circumstantial evidence, the Court found that the prosecution had successfully established the appellant’s guilt.

Background

The prosecution alleges commission of offences punishable under Sections 7 and 13(1)(a) and (d) read with Section 13(2), PC Act and Section 120-B, Penal Code, 1860 (IPC), by Accused 1 and 2, pursuant to a conspiracy between them. In furtherance of the alleged conspiracy, Accused 1, while working as Assistant Engineer, Arakulam Gram Panchayat, first demanded ₹10,000, later scaled it down to ₹5000, and then to ₹4000, for passing bill relating to construction of Pothumattom pond. PW 1 (complainant) was allegedly told to meet appellant in Valikulam Tourist Home, where appellant directed him to place the amount in the measurement book (M-book). PW 1 accordingly placed the trap money there, after which the vigilance team entered and recovered the amount. The prosecution also alleged the involvement of Accused 2, an overseer, on daily wages in the same panchayat.

The Special Judge framed charges for the offences and recorded the evidence. PWs 1 to 10, on the side of the prosecution and DWs 1 and 2, on the defence side, were examined. The trial court convicted appellant for offences of illegal gratification, while holding that the charge of criminal conspiracy under Section 120-B IPC was not proved. Hence, Accused 2 was acquitted of all charges.

Issues

The appellant’s challenge before the High Court was rested on 3 principal grounds.

First, it was argued that the evidence of PW 1, was not trustworthy.

Second, the defence relied on Ext. D-1, a copy of an original petition filed by PW 1, to suggest that the complainant had his own motive to create a trap.

Third, the defence stressed on the evidence of PW 10 [Deputy Superintendent of Police (Deputy SP)], that there was no colour change when the hands of appellant were subjected to phenolphthalein test and therefore the recovery story was doubtful. It was also argued that since PW 1 himself said he had put the money in the M-book, appellant never physically handled the bribe money.

Court’s Ratio and Analysis

On the facts, the Court accepted the prosecution’s version that PW 1 had repeatedly approached the appellant for the release of the payment, and that appellant had demanded illegal gratification on earlier occasions. The Court further accepted that, on the date of the trap, the appellant told PW 1 to place the money inside the M-book. This was supported by the evidence of PW 1, decoy witness PW 2, earlier panchayat Vice President PW 4, and trap officer PW 10. The Court treated the evidence of PW 4 as particularly important because he had spoken about appellant’s demand for money and the delay in release of the payment.

The defence based on Ext. D-1 was rejected because the Court found that the document was not properly used to contradict PW 1 in the manner known to law. Since PW 1 stated that he could not read English, the defence had not properly confronted him with the contents of the document in a language he understood. The Court, therefore, held that Ext. D-1 did not legally discredit the evidence of PW 1. This evidence, according to the Court, strengthened the complainant’s version.

The Court also considered the defence argument based on the negative phenolphthalein test. The testimony of PW 2, and Deputy SP, also supported the prosecution’s version of the trap proceedings. PW 2 described the pre-trap proceedings, handling of the tainted currency notes, demonstration of the phenolphthalein test, and post-trap recovery. PW 10 deposed that Ext. P-5 complaint led to the registration and that Ext. P-5(a) FIR was prepared. The trap team recovered the money from the M-book, and when the corner portion of the notes were tested in sodium carbonate, it turned pink, leading to the seizure of MOs 2 to 11.

The Court acknowledged that the phenolphthalein test conducted on the appellant’s hands did not result in any change of colour. However, it held that this circumstance did not discredit the prosecution’s case. This was because, according to the prosecution version, the money had been placed in the M-book at appellant’s direction and accused was apprehended before any further handling took place. The Court, therefore, concluded that the chemical test result did not help the defence and found that the prosecution had established demand and acceptance of illegal gratification.

Also Read: Mere recovery of tainted money insufficient for conviction under PC Act: Bom HC | SCC Times

The Court’s reasoning was based on the settled principle that demand and acceptance of illegal gratification are sine qua non for conviction under Sections 7 and 13(1)(d), PC Act. The Court expressly relied on Constitutional Bench decision in Neeraj Dutta v. State (NCT of Delhi), (2023) 4 SCC 731 and reiterated the following key legal proposition—

“Proof of demand and acceptance of illegal gratification by a public servant as a fact in issue by the prosecution is a sine qua non in order to establish the guilt of the accused public servant under Sections 7 and 13(1)(d)(i) & (ii), PC Act.”

The Court also reiterated that demand and acceptance can be established oral, documentary, or circumstantial evidence, and further referred to the statutory presumption under Section 20, PC Act in relation to the offences under Section 7, PC Act. Applying these principles to the facts, the Court held that the prosecution had proved that appellant demanded and accepted ₹4000 as bribe in continuation of the earlier demand for ₹10,000, later reduced to ₹5000 and then to ₹4000.

Accordingly, the Court found that the prosecution had established the appellant’s guilt for the offences under the Prevention of Corruption Act and upheld the findings of the Special Judge. It, therefore, held that the appellant’s conviction was justified and warranted no interference.

Also Read: Is it permissible to draw inference of guilt of illegal gratification in case of death of complainant? Larger bench to decide | SCC Times

Decision

The Court upheld the appellant’s conviction under Sections 7 and 13(1)(d) read with Section 13(2) of the Prevention of Corruption Act. However, it modified the sentence to rigorous imprisonment for 1 year and a fine of ₹10,000 for each offence, with a further 2 months’ rigorous imprisonment in default of payment of each fine. The substantive sentences were directed to run concurrently, while the default sentences were to run separately. The Court also allowed set-off and cancelled the suspension of sentence and bail granted to the appellant, directing him to surrender before the Special Court forthwith.

[V.G. Balanchandraji v. State of Kerala, 2026 SCC OnLine Ker 19335, decided on 5-11-2026]


Advocates who appeared in this case :

For the appellant: P. Vijayabhanu, Senior Advocate, P. Maya, P.M. Rafiq

For the Respondent/State: Roy Thomas Muvattupuzha, Senior Public Prosecutor

WhatsApp LinkedIn

0 replies

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *.

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.