Delay of 1400 days cannot be condoned on unsubstantiated explanations; Andhra Pradesh HC restores eviction decree against tenant

condonation of 1400 day delay

Andhra Pradesh High Court: In a civil revision petition under Article 227 of the Constitution and Section 115, Civil Procedure Code, 1908 (CPC), a Single Judge Bench of K. Sreenivasa Reddy, J., set aside orders condoning a delay of 1400 days in applying to set aside an ex parte eviction decree, holding that the tenant had failed to establish sufficient cause or due diligence under Section 5, Limitation Act, 1963.

Also Read: “Jurisdiction under Article 227 is vast, should be exercised sparingly”; Calcutta High Court upholds lower court’s order to condone delay

Background

The landlord (petitioner) filed RCC No. 1 of 2017 under Section 10(2)(i), Andhra Pradesh Buildings (Lease, Rent and Eviction) Control Act, 1960, seeking eviction of the tenant (respondent) on the ground of wilful default in payment of rent. The landlord claimed to have purchased the schedule property by registered sale deed dated 22 April 2017 from Yelisetti Satyanarayana, who held a General Power of Attorney from the tenant, the original owner. The tenant had taken the property on lease from him for 1 year from 10 July 2014 and continued as a monthly tenant.

The tenant entered appearance through counsel on 27 November 2017 but did not file a counter despite several opportunities and was set ex parte on 26 July 2018. The Principal Civil Judge (Junior Division), Anakapalle, allowed the RCC on 13 November 2018, directing her to vacate within 1 month. The landlord then filed an execution petition.

In 2022, the tenant filed an interim application under Section 5, Limitation Act to condone a delay of 1400 days and another interim application to set aside the ex parte decree. She contended that she had no proper contact with her counsel, had no male assistance in her family, and learned of the execution only when the Court Amin came on 1 April 2021. She also said she had filed similar applications on 12 April 2021 which went missing. The landlord opposed, contending that she knew of the proceedings and neglected them until execution was imminent.

On 5 August 2025, the trial court allowed both applications subject to costs of ₹2500, relying on the alleged earlier filings, the Covid-19 Pandemic, the pendency of a partition suit filed by her children, and the absence of male assistance. The landlord challenged both orders in civil revision petitions.

Issues

  1. Whether the trial court was justified in condoning the delay of 1400 days in the absence of a satisfactory and convincing explanation?

  2. Whether the impugned orders warranted interference under Article 227 of the Constitution?

Also Read Conscious decision not to contest suit is not “sufficient cause” for condoning 3650-day delay: Bombay HC

Analysis

The Court reiterated that “sufficient cause” under Section 5 receives a liberal construction to advance substantial justice, provided bona fides and a reasonable explanation are shown, but that this does not give courts unrestricted discretion to condone every delay. The Court relied on Basawaraj v. Special Land Acquisition Officer, (2013) 14 SCC 81, and Esha Bhattacharjee v. Managing Committee of Raghunathpur Nafar Academy, (2013) 12 SCC 649, noting that negligence, lack of bona fides, and want of diligence cannot be ignored, and that inordinate delay calls for a stricter approach.

The Court observed that the tenant had engaged counsel, who filed a vakalatnama on 27 November 2017, so she could be presumed to know of the proceedings from the start. The record showed repeated opportunities to file a counter (22 February 2018, 6 March 2018, 14 March 2018, 12 April 2018, 8 May 2018 and 27 June 2018), all unused. Her claim that she learned of the case only on 1 April 2021 had to be weighed against her earlier appearance through counsel. On the explanations offered, the Court held the claims of no proper contact with counsel and no male assistance, without substantial proof or particulars of how they prevented her from pursuing the case, could not by themselves be sufficient cause.

On the contention put forth by counsel for the respondent that the respondent had filed similar applications and that the delay occurred only because those applications were misplaced, this Court noted that no acknowledgment, filing receipt or other contemporaneous documentary material was produced to substantiate the filing of the said applications. A perusal of the impugned orders shows that the trial Court appears to have accepted this assertion without examining whether the respondent had discharged the burden of establishing it. A mere assertion that certain applications were filed earlier, unsupported by any material, cannot constitute a satisfactory explanation for the substantial delay in approaching the Court. Even assuming, for the sake of argument, that such applications were presented, the respondent was required to explain the delay during the subsequent period of inaction and to establish the steps taken by her to pursue the relief sought.

The Court observed that the Covid-19 Pandemic is relevant but does not automatically explain the entire delay in every case, and the tenant had to show how it prevented her from acting. The pendency of a partition suit by the tenant’s children concerns title and the children’s rights, which are distinct from whether she had sufficient cause for not contesting the eviction proceedings.

The Court found the trial court’s reasons are general in nature and observed that it appeared to have been influenced mainly by the wish to give the tenant an opportunity to contest on merits, rather than independently examining the explanation against the relevant period. It also noted that she had earlier appeared in the execution proceedings and, according to the landlord, had sought relief against an ex parte order there.

The Court acknowledging that Article 227 jurisdiction is supervisory and not appellate, held that interference was warranted because material circumstances had not been properly considered: her failure to prosecute despite appearing, the absence of material for the alleged earlier applications, and the unexplained subsequent inaction.

Also Read 4745 Days Late and No Cogent Explanation: Karnataka HC Dismisses Petition Seeking to File Written Statement in 2006 Suit

Decision

The Court allowed the petitions and set aside the orders dated 5 August 2025. Consequently, interim application filed by the respondent under Section 5, Limitation Act stands dismissed. In view of dismissal of the aforesaid application for condonation of delay, the accompanying application filed seeking to set aside the ex parte eviction order dated 13 November 2018 shall stand rejected as barred by limitation. The petitioner herein is at liberty to proceed with the execution petition proceedings in accordance with law.

[Yelisetti Venkata Lakshmi v. Pottelu Gowri, CRP Nos. 978 and 1064 of 2026, decided on 15-10-2026]


Advocates who appeared in this case:

For the Petitioner: Arrabolu Sai Naveen

For the Respondent: P. Rajasekhar

Join the discussion

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.