Skip to content
Latest Updates
Supreme Court to Establish Permanent Committee on Disability Rights; CJI Surya Kant Directs SCLSC to Set Up Panels of Lawyers and Sign Language Interpreters “Legislature cannot nullify a judgment by enacting law without removing the basis”: Andhra Pradesh High Court strikes down Section 147-A, Income-tax Act, 1961 as unconstitutional ICA and RICS to host Conclave on “Mediation in Transition: Institutional Trust, Professional Standards and the Age of Artificial Intelligence” Cyril Amarchand Mangaldas advises the Placement Agents on INR 3,500 crore QIP by Aegis Logistics Limited Beyond the Code: Monil Chheda on IBC, Restructuring and Distressed Transactions Call for Papers 10.0: Faculty of Law, Maharaja Sayajirao University of Baroda invites submissions for Vox Legis

Delhi High Court directs Voltranic India Lubricants to pay Rs. 1 lakh cost to Castrol Ltd. for infringing its ‘CASTROL’ mark

“Copying of so many marks, labels, packaging, and containers is a deliberate act on defendants’ behalf to gain monetarily by selling counterfeit products.”

Content reader

Listen to this article

Ready to read this article aloud.
Delhi High Court directs Voltranic India Lubricants to pay Rs. 1 lakh cost to Castrol Ltd. for infringing its ‘CASTROL’ mark
Delhi High Court directs Voltranic India Lubricants to pay Rs. 1 lakh cost to Castrol Ltd. for infringing its ‘CASTROL’ mark

Delhi High Court: Plaintiff 1, Castrol Ltd. and Plaintiff 2, Castrol India Ltd. filed the present suit seeking permanent injunction restraining defendants from infringement of trade mark and copyright, passing off, piracy of design, rendition of accounts of profits, damages, delivery up, acts of unfair competition etc. Prathiba M. Singh, J.*, opined that there was counterfeiting of lubricants, greases and oils which were used in automobiles and any compromise in quality of such products could have adverse consequences on customers. The Court thus directed that a sum of Rs. 1 lakh was to be paid as cost by defendants to plaintiffs.

Background

Plaintiffs were manufacturing and selling lubricants, oil, grease, and other related products used in the automobile industry. Plaintiffs adopted the mark ‘CASTROL’ for various oils, greases, high grade lubricants and other related services in the automotive, industrial, and marine and aviation sectors. Apart from the mark ‘CASTROL’, plaintiffs also use various other marks including ‘CASTROL ACTIV’, ‘ACTIV’, ‘RADICOOL’, ‘GTX’, ‘MAGNATEC’, ‘CASTROL POWER’ and ‘EDGE’.

Plaintiffs submitted that in 2019 they learnt that defendants were infringing the registered trade marks of plaintiffs by selling identical products with brand name ‘VOLTRONIC’, used in conjunction with plaintiff’s trade marks ‘ACTIVE’, ‘RADICOOL’, ‘GTX’, ‘POWER 1’, ‘MAGNATEC’ and ‘EDGE’. Plaintiffs claimed that their products were sold in distinctive containers, which had also been copied by defendants. Plaintiffs sent a cease and desist notice to defendants on 04-07-2019 however, no response was received. Plaintiffs thereafter purchased defendants’ product and found that they were selling counterfeit products. Thus, plaintiffs filed the present suit.

Delhi High Court directs Voltranic India Lubricants to pay Rs. 1 lakh cost to Castrol Ltd. for infringing its ‘CASTROL’ mark   Delhi High Court directs Voltranic India Lubricants to pay Rs. 1 lakh cost to Castrol Ltd. for infringing its ‘CASTROL’ mark

Delhi High Court directs Voltranic India Lubricants to pay Rs. 1 lakh cost to Castrol Ltd. for infringing its ‘CASTROL’ mark

Analysis, Law, and Decision

The Court vide order dated 16-01-2020 granted an ex-parte injunction restraining defendants and appointed a local commissioner, who visited defendants’ premises. However, there was no cooperation by defendants, and they completely denied having made any sales of the counterfeited products.

The Court opined that defendants were clearly engaging in manufacturing and sale of counterfeit products and the copying of so many marks, labels, packaging, and containers was a deliberate act on behalf of defendants to gain monetarily by selling counterfeit products. The Court also opined that there was counterfeiting of lubricants, greases and oils which were used in automobiles and any compromise in quality of such products could have adverse consequences on customers.

The Court set aside the order dated 16-01-2020 as defendants were willing to pay the costs. Thus, the Court directed that a sum of Rs. 1 lakh was to be paid as cost by defendants to plaintiffs.

[Castrol Ltd. v. Voltranic India Lubricants, 2023 SCC OnLine Del 7641, decided on 30-11-2023]

*Judgment authored by: Justice Prathiba M. Singh


Advocates who appeared in this case :

For the Plaintiffs: Afzal B. Khan, Samik Mukherjee, Suhrita Majumdar, Sharad Besoy, Advocates

For the Defendants: Sanjeev Gupta, Pritama, Rahul Saini, Ravish Sharma, Advocates

WhatsApp LinkedIn

0 replies

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *.

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.