Skip to content

Post-decree deposit cannot retrospectively revive right to defend summary suit under Order 37 CPC: J&K and Ladakh HC

Failure to comply with the conditions imposed for leave to defend a summary suit cannot be cured by a post-decree deposit; the right to defend, once forfeited, cannot be retrospectively revived.

Content reader

Listen to this article

Ready to read this article aloud.
Post-decree deposit cannot retrospectively revive right to defend summary suit under Order 37 CPC: J&K and Ladakh HC

Jammu & Kashmir and Ladakh High Court: In a matter concerning the right to defend a summary trial under Order 37, Civil Procedure Code, 1908 (CPC), a Single Judge Bench of Moksha Khajuria Kazmi, J., held that non-compliance with the conditions imposed for grant of leave to defend, coupled with post decree deposit of amount cannot retrospectively revive the right to defend. While dismissing the appeal, the Court noted that no cogent explanation had been furnished by the appellants justifying their failure to deposit the balance amount within the time granted by the trial court. Finding no perversity or illegality, it upheld the trial court order in favour of the respondents.

Also Read: Grant of leave to defend is the ordinary rule and denial is an exception; Supreme Court lays down detailed guidelines for leave to defend in summary suits | SCC Times

Background

The appeal stems from the judgment and decree passed by the Additional District Judge (Bank Cases) (trial court), Srinagar in a summary suit in favour of the respondents an amount of ₹57.23 lakhs along with interest and costs.

The respondents claimed to have executed electrical works at the MLA Hostel, Srinagar (Hostel) during 2019—2020. They stated that the works were carried out on verbal instructions of the appellants particularly the then Executive Engineer, Estates Division, and involved expenditure of about ₹57.32 lakhs.

They alleged that ₹18.35 lakhs were incurred in 2019 at the verbal direction of the District Magistrate, Srinagar, for facilities for political leaders confined at the Hostel after the abrogation of Article 370 of the Constitution of India. Works worth ₹37.82 lakhs were executed using the funds contributed by the Legislative Assembly Secretariat and released to the Directorate of Estates, with no public tendering process.

The respondents filed a summary suit under Order 37 CPC before the trial court, seeking recovery of ₹57.32 lakhs along with interest and costs. The appellants sought leave to defend the suit. The trial court, by order dated 21 December 2022, allowed conditional leave to defend, subject to deposit of ₹37.82 lakhs and filing of a written statement within 30 days.

The appellants deposited ₹19.01 lakhs on 26 March 2023 but did not deposit the balance of ₹18.81 lakhs within the stipulated period. The trial court thus decreed the suit on 12 August 2023 for ₹57.23 lakhs, along with interest and costs, because the condition for leave to defend remained unfulfilled. The balance amount of ₹18.81 lakhs was deposited only on 25 July 2025, much after the decree.

Aggrieved by the order dated 12 August 2023 (impugned order); the appellants filed the present appeal.

Contentions

Appellants: They primarily challenged the impugned order on the ground that substantial portion of the amount directed to be deposited by the trial court had already been deposited, but the same was not considered by the trial court while passing the impugned order. They also contended that the trial court also failed to consider the peculiar circumstances which occasioned the delay in depositing the remaining amount.

Respondents: They contended that the appellants in their application seeking leave to defend, had admitted that the works in question, to the extent of ₹37.82 lakhs had been executed by the respondents. It was further contended that the appellants failed to comply with the condition imposed by the order dated 21 December 2022. They submitted that the balance amount was deposited only in the year 2025, much after the passing of the impugned order, and therefore the present appeal is devoid of merit and is not maintainable.

Also Read: Explained| Grant of Leave to Defend: The best approach | SCC Times

Court’s Analysis

The Court noted that the trial court had granted leave to defend subject to the deposit of Rs. 37.82 lakh and the filing of a written statement within 30 days. Against this amount, the appellants deposited Rs. 19.01 lakh on 26 March 2023, while the remaining Rs. 18.81 lakh was deposited only on 25 July 2025.

The Court observed that the suit had already been decreed on 12 August 2023, much before the deposit of the balance amount. It held that the deposit made on 25 July 2025, after the passing of the decree, could not be treated as compliance with the trial court’s direction retrospectively so as to revive the right to defend the suit.

The Court also noted that the appellants also failed to place on record any cogent explanation justifying their failure to deposit the balance amount within the time granted by the trial court. Thus, there is no illegality or perversity in the impugned order passed by the trial court.

Decision

Finding no perversity or illegality in the impugned judgment and decree, the Court upheld the trial court’s decision and dismissed the civil first appeal as devoid of merit.

[State (UT of J&K) v. Shabir Ahmad Dar, RFA No. 31/2024, decided on 13-11-2026]


Advocates who appeared in this case:

For the Appellants: Illyas Nazir Laway, Government Advocate.

For the Respondents: Manzoor Ahmad Dar, Javaid, Advocates.

WhatsApp LinkedIn

0 replies

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *.

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.