Introduction1
In August 2017, the first resolution plan approved under the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code, 2016 (IBC) gave the lenders of Synergies Dooray Automotive Ltd. a haircut of about 94 per cent. The plan came from a group company of the promoter, and it was carried by a committee of creditors dominated by an assignee of a related party’s debt. The tribunals held that nothing in the text of the Code was breached.2 Within three months, Parliament inserted Section 29-A by Ordinance.3 The Synergies case4 is remembered less for what it decided than for what it exposed: The text allowed a debtor’s own circle to decide the fate of a debtor’s own debts.
The personal insolvency of Dr Subhash Chandra is Part III’s version of that moment. Against admitted claims of about Rs 22,006.57 crores, his repayment plan offers Rs. 6.5 crores, a recovery of roughly 0.03 per cent. The plan was approved by 80.814 per cent of the voting creditors. Five of those creditors, together holding 61.78 per cent of the vote, are entities said to be controlled by his relatives. Two members of the National Company Law Tribunal (NCLT) disagreed, a third member gave a third view, and the case now sits before a five-Member Special Bench of the NCLT, presided over by its President.5 This piece traces that journey, examines the interpretive gap at its centre, and argues that the real answer lies, as in 2017, with Parliament.
Before Subhash Chandra, there was “Synergies Dooray”
The parallel of the Subhash Chandra case6 with the 2017 Synergies Dooray is close, and it is worth stating precisely.
In Synergies Dooray, the related party, Synergies Castings Ltd., held about 78 per cent of the corporate debtor’s financial debt and was barred from the committee of creditors by the proviso to Section 21(2). It assigned that debt to Millennium Finance Ltd. The Millennium-led committee approved, by 91.06 per cent, a plan submitted by Synergies Castings itself, with a haircut of about 94 per cent. The National Company Law Appellate Tribunal (NCLAT) held that the assignment was valid and that the assignee was not a related party, because nothing in the text said otherwise.7 The NCLAT took the opposite view in Pankaj Yadav v. SBI8, where an assignee of the promoter’s debt was held to take the assignor’s disqualification with it. The Insolvency Law Committee was asked to exclude debt assigned within a year before insolvency, but thought the existing related-party bar sufficient.9 Parliament, by then, had already moved on the larger problem: Section 29-A closed the door to promoters and their connected persons as resolution applicants. And in 2021, in Spade Financial10, the Supreme Court read the proviso to Section 21(2) to exclude a creditor who was a related party when the debt was created, where the relationship had been shed to get into the committee of creditors, because the object of the Bar is to keep conflicted creditors out of decisions on the debtor’s fate.
The same pattern repeats in Part III. Creditors within the debtor’s family circle hold the decisive vote; the plan returns almost nothing to independent lenders; and the tribunal that upholds the vote does so, by its own account, because the text is narrower than the mischief.
Subhash Chandra Case
The process and the vote
Now, comes the elephant in the room. In this matter, one creditor, namely, Indiabulls Housing Finance Ltd. filed a Section 95 application against Dr Chandra, as personal guarantor to group companies, in 2022. A resolution professional (RP) was appointed on 30 May 2022, the proceedings were kept in abeyance while the constitutional challenge to Part III was pending before the Supreme Court, and the application was admitted on 22 April 2024.11 The RP was replaced on 27 May 2024.12
The repayment plan was submitted on 16 October 2024, which offered Rs 6.25 crores to creditors and Rs. 25 lakhs towards process costs. LIC Housing Finance, with an admitted claim of Rs 1,322.39 crores, was to receive Rs 38,09,294.13 Pertinently, the guarantor in the present case had declared their net worth to the tune of Rs 31.79 crores approximately, wherein the creditors claimed that the net-worth certificates given to lenders in 2017 and 2018 had put it at about Rs 45,888 crores and Rs 40,562 crores, respectively.14
The voting record explains the dispute:
-
World Crest Advisors LLP (28.49 per cent)
-
Lemonade Capital Advisors LLP (16.85 per cent)
-
Corpcall Capital Advisors LLP (10.30 per cent)
-
Veena Investments (P) Ltd. (4.99 per cent)
-
Direct Media Distribution Ventures (P) Ltd. (1.15 per cent)
The abovementioned entities, all had voted in favour of the plan. On the other hand, the naysayers included majorly every bank.15
Tracing the roots of “Veena Investments”, it is stated that the same is controlled by the wife of the guarantor’s brother. “Direct Media” and “World Crest” are its subsidiaries. Partners of “Lemonade” and “Corpcall” were Directors of companies shown as “other related parties” in Veena’s consolidated financial statements. What is material to note is that some claims rested on those guarantees or indemnities given by the guarantor, that stood invoked after the interim moratorium had begun.16 To that, the NCLT had opined “[t]he allegation that the said guarantees were invoked during the interim moratorium period is of no legal consequence as, for filing of a claim and its admission by the RP, the guarantees don’t need to be invoked”17.
Once the related party claims are excluded, the calculations show that the plan does not come close to the three-fourths majority required by Section 111.18 Two further claims, lodged by two individuals on behalf of 960 and 300 persons, were admitted on the guarantor’s statement that he had verbally promised them financial help; they had no documents.19 However, in the final order, the third member excluded those claims.20
Under Section 109(4)(b), a creditor who is an “associate” of the debtor cannot vote. Whether these five entities were “associates” was therefore decisive, which stipulates:
79. Definitions.
(2) “associate” of the debtor means—
(a) a person who belongs to the immediate family of the debtor;
(b) a person who is a relative of the debtor or a relative of the spouse of the debtor;
(c) a person who is in partnership with the debtor;
(d) a person who is a spouse or a relative of any person with whom the debtor is in partnership;
(e) a person who is employer of the debtor or employee of the debtor;
(f) a person who is a trustee of a trust in which the beneficiaries of the trust include a debtor, or the terms of the trust confer a power on the trustee which may be exercised for the benefit of the debtor; and
(g) a company, where the debtor or the debtor along with his associates, own more than fifty per cent of the share capital of the company or control the appointment of the board of directors of the company.
Explanation.— For the purposes of this sub-section, “relative”, with reference to any person, means anyone who is related to another, if
(i) they are members of a Hindu Undivided Family;
(ii) one person is related to the other in such manner as may be prescribed.
The Division Bench (3 September 2025)
The Member (Judicial), held that none of the five entities was an associate. Section 79(2)(g) treats a company as an associate where “the debtor or the debtor along with his associates” own more than half its share capital or control its board, and the guarantor held no shares in any of them. He approved the plan, but used Section 115(1) to bind only the creditors who had voted for it, leaving the dissenting banks free to recover their debts outside the plan.21
The Member (Technical), rejected the plan, while reading the second limb of Section 79(2)(g) as aggregating the holdings of the debtor’s associates, so that a company controlled by the debtor’s sister-in-law, herself an associate, is caught even if the debtor holds no shares. In other words, since it was an admitted position that the debtor does not hold any shares in Veena Investments Pvt Ltd, the controversy, therefore, centered around whether the provision would also encompass a company in which while the debtor has no direct shareholding, but where an individual who unquestionably qualifies as his associate-namely, the wife of his brother-holds a controlling stake.
The Member (Technical), opined that any other interpretation would allow an associate escape the bar by routing a claim through a company, otherwise. Further breaches of Sections 100(2), 106(4), 107(1), 108(4) and 110(5), were found. The Member (Technical) also found issues with the admission of claims without verification by the RP, all the while declining a forensic audit.22
The third member (25 August 2026)
On a reference under Section 419(5), Companies Act, 2013, the matter went to the 3rd Member (Judicial).23 It was opined that Section 114 does not make approval automatic as the Adjudicating Authority must satisfy itself that the process was lawful, and may reject the plan, or send it back under Section 114(3).24 It was also opined that a RP in Chapter III of Part III has no investigative powers of the kind given to a bankruptcy trustee under Section 149; a forensic audit is not a precondition to approval; and a fall in net worth, without proof of concealment, is a ground for questions and not for rejection.25
On the associate question, he sided with the Member (Judicial). The test in Section 79(2)(g) is legal ownership or control, not influence or family proximity; the narrower language of Part III, compared with Section 29-A and the definitions of “related party” in Sections 5(24) and 5(24-A), is deliberate; and Phoenix ARC (P) Ltd. v. Spade Financial Services Ltd.26 was confined to “related party” under Part II and to a finding of collusion.27 Then came two significant sentences:
“However, there is no doubt about the fact that the said entities are controlled directly or indirectly by the individuals related to the PG. Legislature has adopted legal ownership and control, not commercial influence, as the statutory standard.”28
and
“[i]f experience shows that a wider exclusion is necessary, it is for the Legislature, and not the Tribunal, to amend the provision.”29
While excluding the 960 and 300 claims, holding their admission erroneous, it was held that the aforesaid defect did not affect the outcome.30 Resultantly, the plan was approved. Departing from the Member (Judicial), it was held that Section 115 does not permit selective application: once approved, the plan binds all creditors, assenting or dissenting.31
The five-Member Special Bench
On 31 August 2026, the original Bench recorded that “no majority view has emerged”: One Member had rejected the plan, one had approved it for the assenting creditors only, and one had approved it for all creditors. It made a fresh reference to the President under Section 419(5).32 The President constituted a five-Member Special Bench the same day. On 1 September 2026, the Special Bench stayed the third Member’s order and directed the guarantor not to alienate any assets, directly or indirectly.33 On 23 September 2026, being told that the Central Bureau of Investigation (CBI) was investigating matters that could bear on the case, it issued notice to the Director of the CBI, continued the interim directions until final disposal, and listed the matter for arguments on 19 November 2026.34
The procedural result is itself worth a moment. Section 419(5) contemplates a point of difference being decided “according to the opinion of the majority of Members of the Tribunal who have heard the case, including those who first heard it”. On approval, two of the three Members were in favour; on the reach of Section 115, the two who reached the question disagreed. That is why no operative order could be drawn. The five-Member Bench will now have to decide not only the merits but also how its own view is to be counted with the three opinions already given.
Why Part III leaves the gap
“Associate” is not “related party”
Part III uses two different concepts. Section 109(4)(b), which governs voting on a repayment plan, uses “associate”, defined in Section 79(2): relatives, partners, employers and employees, trustees, and under clause (g) a company in which the debtor, or the debtor along with his associates, holds more than 50 per cent or controls the board.
Section 5(24-A), inserted in 2018, defines a “related party” in relation to an individual far more widely. It covers a body corporate whose board acts on the individual’s advice, directions or instructions [cl. (f)], and a limited liability partnership whose partners act on his advice [cl. (g)].35 Parliament added the wider definition, but never carried it into Section 109(4)(b). The Insolvency and Bankruptcy Board of India (IBBI) itself has described the definition of “associate” as “much narrower”, and illustrated the gap with a company that “habitually acts on the guarantor’s advice or instructions” without his holding shares in it.36
The combined limb of Section 79(2)(g)
On the narrower definition, the case turns on the words “the debtor along with his associates”. It is submitted that the Original Member (Technical)’s reading has the better of the argument. If the aggregate holdings (even if devoid of any holding by the guarantor but only owned by the associate) are not excluded from voting share, the result produced is that while individually a relative herself being an associate cannot vote; but she can vote through a company she wholly owns. A construction that lets the bar be avoided by one corporate layer does not serve that object. In fact, in such cases, corporate veil has to be lifted.
The same also raises further questions:
1. What if the associate votes through a partnership (with their partner being a random 3rd party)?
Surely, one would say that since there is no separate entity in a partnership, a bar on the associate, operates as a bar on the partnership firms (where such an associate is a partner) as well. Now the question would be:
2. What if the associate votes through an LLP (with their partner being a random 3rd party)?
Now the third Member’s reasoning points out one differential. Disqualifications from voting take away a statutory right and should not be extended by analogy; and Spade Financial did rest on a finding of collusion that was not made here.37 But the two points do not meet. Reading “along with his associates” to aggregate associates’ holdings is not extension by analogy; it is a choice between two meanings of the words used. Hence, the invocation of the tool of purposive interpretation. Where one meaning lets the mischief through and the other does not, the purposive approach endorsed in Spade Financial points to the second.
Why a regulation will not be enough and beyond the vote
The IBBI’s Discussion Paper proposes to give a related party of the guarantor, as defined in Section 5(24-A), a “Nil” voting share, by amending the IBBI (Insolvency Resolution Process for Personal Guarantors to Corporate Debtors) Regulations, 2019 under Sections 109(2) and 240(2)(zq).38 The direction is right, but there are two limits.
First, vires. Section 109(4) lists the creditors who “shall not be entitled to vote”. Section 109(2) leaves to the Board only the “manner” of determining a creditor’s voting share. A regulation that assigns a zero voting share to a class of creditors whom the Code otherwise leaves eligible to vote would, in effect, amount to introducing an additional disqualification, thereby exceeding the scope of the legislative authority delegated by the parent statute. Section 29-A was enacted by Parliament, not by regulation, and that is the right model here.
Secondly, reach. Clause (i) of Section 5(24-A) repeats the same structure, “the individual or the individual along with its related party”, so a Veena-type company would still depend on how the combined limb is read. The influence limbs in clauses (f) and (g) would catch entities such as Lemonade and Corpcall only if it is shown that they act on the guarantor’s instructions, which brings back the same questions of proof.
The case exposes three further gaps, all of which the IBBI has now identified.
Verification and valuation: The third Member held that the RP in Chapter III has no power to investigate, and that the Code requires no valuation of the guarantor’s assets.39 In Corporate Insolvency Resolution Process (CIRP), a registered valuer must determine fair value and liquidation value, and the RP must place avoidance transactions before the committee of creditors. In Part III, the only check on a guarantor who says that his Rs. 40,000-crore estate has shrunk to Rs. 31 crores is his own statement of affairs. The IBBI proposes mandatory valuation and a review of transactions under Sections 164, 164-A, 165 and 167 at the resolution stage, with the RP empowered to act on them.40
Reasons for accepting a 99.97 per cent haircut: Creditors in CIRP must record why a plan is feasible and viable. No such record is required for a repayment plan. The IBBI proposes one, with specific reasons where the payout is far below admitted claims or realisable value.41
The effect of Section 115: The Member (Judicial)’s attempt to bind only assenting creditors was a remedy for a suspect vote. With respect, the 3rd Member was right that Section 115 does not allow it: A plan binds all creditors named in it, and a discharge under Section 119 follows completion. That is exactly why the integrity of the vote matters so much. Once approved, a plan voted through by the debtor’s circle extinguishes the independent creditors’ claims on the guarantee for 0.03 per cent. The IBBI’s circular of 9 September 2026 on misuse of the IBC also shows how close the two moments are. Its first red flag is a CIRP initiated by, or debt assigned shortly before initiation to, a single creditor who then dominates the committee of creditors.42 That is the Synergies pattern, nine years later. But the circular is addressed to CIRP and liquidation. Part III has no counterpart.
What reform should look like
-
Amend Section 109(4)(b) to bar creditors who are associates or related parties [Section 5(24-A)] of the debtor, and clarify that the combined limbs of Sections 79(2)(g) and 5(24-A)(i) aggregate the holdings of associates or related parties even where the debtor holds none.
-
Adopt the Spade Financial check on collusion rule in the statute: Where the bar should apply where the relationship existed when the debt or guarantee was created, and not only on the date of voting.
-
Attempt must be to lift the corporate veil as done by the Supreme Court in the matter of Arcelormittal India (P) Ltd. v. Satish Kumar Gupta43, to ensure Section 29-A was not bypassed.
-
Require claims by related parties founded on guarantees or indemnities from the debtor to be supported by documents and contemporaneous accounting entries, and flag claims on guarantees invoked after the interim moratorium began.
-
Make valuation and avoidance-transaction review mandatory in the resolution process, as the IBBI proposes, and give the RP the power to seek directions on them.
-
Extend the IBBI’s misuse indicators to Part III, so that the RP must apply to the Adjudicating Authority where the vote depends on connected creditors.
-
In cases, where a guarantor’s declared net worth has collapsed, creditors should apply early for non-alienation orders. The Special Bench granted one on 1 September 2026; it came after the vote, not before it.
Conclusion
The third Member’s opinion is candid about its own limits: The entities that carried the vote were, in his words, controlled “directly or indirectly by the individuals related to the PG”, but the text did not reach them. That is what the Synergies Tribunals said in 2017, in substance, and Parliament’s reply was Section 29-A. The five-Member Bench may yet read Section 79(2)(g) as the Member (Technical) did, and there is a sound textual case for doing so. But whatever it decides, the case for legislative change does not depend on the outcome. A repayment plan should be decided by creditors who are independent of the debtor. Part III needs its own Section 29-A moment, and a regulation is not a substitute for it.
*Akaant Kumar Mittal, Founder — Blue Stone Chambers of Law, at https://bluestonechambersoflaw.com. Advocate, Constitutional Courts and National Company Law Tribunals, Delhi and Chandigarh; Specialist Visiting Faculty, National Law University, Mumbai; Visiting Lecturer, National University of Juridical Sciences, Kolkata; author of Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code — Law and Practice (EBC, 2nd Edn., 2023).
**Bhavana Garg, Independent Practitioner and Advocate, Constitutional Courts and National Company Law Tribunals, Delhi and Chandigarh, B.Com.-LL.B. and LL.M.
1. Part of the discussion here is discussed in detail in the commentary titled “Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code: Law and Practice” (In 2 Volumes) accessible here.
2. Edelweiss Asset Reconstruction Co. Ltd. v. Synergies Dooray Automotive Ltd., 2018 SCC OnLine NCLAT 1005. The plan was approved by the NCLT, Hyderabad in August 2017.
3. Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code (Amendment) Ordinance, 2017, replaced by the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code (Amendment) Act, 2018 (8 of 2018).
4. Edelweiss Asset Reconstn. v. Synergies Dooray, (2019) 6 Comp Cas-OL 615
5. Indiabulls Housing Finance Ltd. v. Dr. Subhash Chandra, 2026 SCC OnLine NCLT 5267
6. Indiabulls Housing Finance Ltd. v. Dr. Subhash Chandra, 2026 SCC OnLine NCLT 5267
7. Edelweiss Asset Reconstn. v. Synergies Dooray, (2019) 6 Comp Cas-OL 615
9. Ministry of Corporate Affairs, Report of the Insolvency Law Committee (March 2018) p. 23 para 1.25.
10. Phoenix ARC (P) Ltd. v. Spade Financial Services Ltd., (2021) 3 SCC 475
11. Indiabulls Housing Finance Ltd. v. Subhash Chandra, CP (IB) No. 97/ND/2022, opinion of the Third Member dated 25-8-2026 (NCLT, New Delhi) (Third Member’s opinion), pp. 6-7, referring to the interim order of the Supreme Court dated 5-8-2022 in WP (C) No. 567 of 2022. See Dilip B. Jiwrajka v. Union of India, (2024) 5 SCC 435.
12. Indiabulls Housing Finance Ltd. v. Subhash Chandra, pp. 7-8 (IA No. 2148 of 2024).
13. Indiabulls Housing Finance Ltd. v. Subhash Chandra, written submissions of LIC Housing Finance Ltd., recorded at p. 54.
14. Indiabulls Housing Finance Ltd. v. Subhash Chandra, p. 38 and paras 36-38.
15. Indiabulls Housing Finance Ltd. v. Subhash Chandra, pp. 16-17, extracting the voting record from para 4.6 of IA No. 6125 of 2024. Axis Bank, Canara Bank, HDFC Bank, IDBI Trusteeship (Franklin Templeton), LIC Housing Finance, RBL Bank and Union Bank of India (UK) voted against.
16. Indiabulls Housing Finance Ltd. v. Subhash Chandra, pp. 29-32; Third Member’s opinion, Issue VII and answer to question 4(a) of the Member (Technical).
17. Indiabulls Housing Finance Ltd. v. Subhash Chandra, p. 142; Third Member’s opinion.
18. On the voting record, creditors with about 95.90 per cent of the voting share voted, and those in favour held about 77.48 per cent (80.8 per cent of the votes cast). In other words, without the five entities, the votes in favour fall to about 15.7 per cent of the voting share, well short of three-fourths however the base is computed. The figures are the author’s, from the voting record cited above.
19. See, Third Member’s opinion, paras 86-88, extracting the minutes of the first meeting of creditors.
20. Third Member’s opinion, p.144.
21. As summarised in the Third Member’s opinion, pp. 22-27, and in the order of the original Bench dated 31-8-2026, paras 1-2.
22. As summarised in the Third Member’s opinion, pp. 28-45.
23. The order of the Special Bench dated 1-9-2026 records that the then President, NCLT referred the difference to the Third Member on 5-2-2026; the Third Member’s opinion refers to a reference order dated 9-2-2026.
24. Third Member’s opinion, pp. 134, 135; paras 14, 16.
25. Third Member’s opinion, paras 26-44 and 57-59.
27. Third Member’s opinion, paras 61-68 and 71, and p. 138.
28. Third Member’s opinion, para 72.
29. Third Member’s opinion, para 73.
30. Third Member’s opinion, paras 86-90 and 91-100.
31. Third Member’s opinion, paras 106-107 and 113; Order, paras (a) to (c).
32. Indiabulls Housing Finance Ltd. v. Subhash Chandra, order dated 31-8-2026 (NCLT, New Delhi, Court II), paras 3-6.
33. Order of the Special Bench dt. 1-9-2026, supra, paras 5-9; NCLT Office Order dt. 31-8-2026 constituting the Special Bench under S. 419(5), Companies Act, 2013.
34. Indiabulls Housing Finance Ltd. v. Subhash Chandra, order dated 23-9-2026 (NCLT, New Delhi, Special Bench), paras 3-5.
35. Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code, 2016, S. 5(24-A), inserted by Act 26 of 2018, w.e.f. 6-6-2018.
36. Insolvency and Bankruptcy Board of India, Discussion Paper, “Strengthening safeguards in the Insolvency Resolution Process for Personal Guarantors to Corporate Debtors” (comments invited till 3-10-2026), Proposal 1, paras 1-2.
37. Third Member’s opinion, paras 69 and 71.
38. IBBI Discussion Paper, “Strengthening safeguards in the Insolvency Resolution Process for Personal Guarantors to Corporate Debtors” Proposal 1, paras 3 and 5 (proposed proviso to Regn. 11(2) and amendment of Regn. 9(1) of the IBBI (Insolvency Resolution Process for Personal Guarantors to Corporate Debtors) Regulations, 2019).
39. Third Member’s opinion, paras 31, 42-44.
40. IBBI Discussion Paper, “Strengthening safeguards in the Insolvency Resolution Process for Personal Guarantors to Corporate Debtors”, Proposals 2 and 3 (proposed Regns. 10-A and 10-B).
41. IBBI Discussion Paper, “Strengthening safeguards in the Insolvency Resolution Process for Personal Guarantors to Corporate Debtors” Proposal 4 [proposed Regn. 15(2-A)], modelled on Regn. 39(3)(b) of the CIRP Regulations, but expanded to cover situations “where the amount proposed to be paid to creditors under the repayment plan is significantly lower than the amount of their admitted claims or the estimated realisable value of the assets of the guarantor”.
42. Insolvency and Bankruptcy Board of India, Circular No. IBBI/CIRP/105/2026 dt. 9-9-2026, para 2(a).
43. (2019) 2 SCC 1, in para 96 it was stated:
96. The excerpted portions of Numetal’s resolution plan make it clear that, since Numetal itself was a newly incorporated entity, with no financial or experience credentials of its own, it therefore relied entirely on the credentials of each of its constituent shareholders. This shows that Numetal itself revealed in its resolution plan that its corporate veil should be lifted, for without lifting this veil, none of the parameters of the request for proposal could have been met by Numetal itself…





0 replies