SCC Weekly 2016 SCC Vol. 2 February 21, 2016 Part 3
Criminal Procedure Code, 1973 — Ss. 311 and 313 — Recall of witnesses under S. 311 — When permissible and warranted: Plea of recall has to be bona fide. Mere (in)competence/change of counsel cannot be ground for recall of witnesses. Recall cannot be allowed on plea that defence counsel (previous)…
SCC Weekly 2016 SCC Vol. 1 January 14, 2016 Part 2
Civil Procedure Code, 1908 — Or. 1 Rr. 3 and 10(2) and S. 115 — Impleadment as defendants when original defendants set ex parte: As the impleadment application moved by appellants for impleading themselves as defendants when original defendants set ex parte, was allowed by trial court, but set aside…
SCC Weekly 2016 SCC Vol. 2 February 7, 2016 Part 1
Civil Procedure Code, 1908 — Or. 22 R. 2 — Partial abatement of suit and appeal — When possible: As one of several plaintiffs died during pendency of appeal before High Court and LRs not brought on record and each one of the plaintiffs having independent and distinct right of…
SCC Weekly 2016 SCC Vol. 1 January 28, 2016 Part 4
Arbitration Act, 1940 — Ss. 2(b), 14, 30 and 33 — Non-speaking award — Interference by court: In view of clause providing for payment by employer in case of increase in statutory levies and statutory increase in steel prices, disputes as to claims for statutory escalation in taxes and steel…
SCC Weekly 2016 SCC Vol. 1 January 21, 2016 Part 3
Building and Other Construction Workers’ Welfare Cess Act, 1996 — S. 3 — Cess on construction works: Cess on construction works could be imposed even prior to date of constitution of the State Board (the M.P. Building and Other Construction Workers’ Welfare Board in this case). [A. Prabhakara Reddy &…
SCC Weekly 2016 SCC Vol. 1 January 14, 2016 Part 2
Central Excise Act, 1944 — S. 4(4)(d)(i) — Cost of packaging: The appellant had charged for the value of the gunny bags from the customers by adding the same to the cost of soda ash and relied on letters dated 15-12-1970, 1-2-1971 and 2-4-1971, to show that there was an…
SCC Weekly 2016 SCC Vol. 1 January 7, 2016 Part 1
Central Excise Act, 1944 — S. 11-B (as amended in 1991) — Refund: Amended provisions of S. 11-B are not applicable to applications for refund initiated and which had attained finality by order of refund by Tribunal under previous provisions. Mere pendency of implementation of order of refund does not…
SCC Weekly 2015 SCC Vol. 10 December 28, 2015 Part 5
Central Excise Rules, 1944 — Rr. 173-G, 9 and 49 — CENVAT Credit: Payment of duty through CENVAT Credit is as good as making payment through account current [prior to amendment of R. 8 of 2002 Rules inserting of sub-rule (3-A) vide Notification No. 17/05-C.E.(N.T.) dt. 31-3-2005 w.e.f. 1-4-2005]. Utilisation…
SCC Weekly 2015 SCC Vol. 10 December 21, 2015 Part 4
Civil Procedure Code, 1908 — Or. 37 R. 3 — Summary suit — Leave to Defend: Where the defendant has raised a triable issue or a reasonable defence, the defendant is entitled to unconditional leave to defend. Leave is granted to defend even in cases where the defendant upon disclosing…




