Foreign Courts Court rejects the Appeal of the Government of South Africa in Al-Bashir case
Supreme Court of Appeal (SCA): In a matter arising out of the indictment of the incumbent President of Sudan – Omar Hassan Ahmad Al Bashir by the International Criminal Court, who was charged for committing genocide, crimes against humanity and war crimes, a five judge bench of Lewis, Ponnan, Shongwe,…
Foreign Courts Application of new procedure in terms of amendments to the Judicial Service Commission Act 9...
Supreme Court of Appeal of South Africa– Deciding on an important issue as to the legitimacy of steps taken by the Judicial Service Commission (JSC) pursuant to the complaint lodged by 11 Justices of the Constitutional Court with the first respondent (JSC), the only body empowered to receive and deal…
Foreign Courts South African Parliament directed to comply with the Statutory Language requirements
Supreme Court of Appeal (SCA): In an interesting constitutional matter, a five-judge Bench comprising Lewis, Ponnan (JJA), Seriti (JJA), Fourie (AJJA) and Plasket (AJJA) dismissed the demand for publication of all the statutes in 11 different official languages, but directed the Parliament to comply with the language requirements as provided…
Foreign Courts Chan Wing-Siu principle with regard to accessory liability overturned
Supreme Court of United Kingdom– Deciding on an important issue concerning the mental element of intent which must be proved when a defendant is accused of being a secondary party to a crime and whether the common law took a wrong turning in two cases, Chan Wing-Siu v The Queen…
Foreign Courts Euthanasia – Canadian perspective
By Vidya Sagar
Foreign Courts High Court of Australia upholds indefinite detention of asylum seekers in a foreign country
High Court of Australia: Rejecting the challenge to the constitutionality of the offshore processing system, the High Court in a landmark judgment has upheld Australia’s role in detaining asylum seekers in foreign countries. The Full Court by a majority held that the conduct of Commonwealth in securing, funding and participating…
Foreign Courts ‘Habitual residence’ must be interpreted in a way that it corresponds to the place which...
Supreme Court of United Kingdom– Deciding on an important issue with regard to the point at which habitual residence of the child was lost, the Court by a ratio of 3:2 observed that the modern concept of a child’s habitual residence operates in a manner that makes it highly unlikely…
Foreign Courts Constitutionality of 7(1) (a) of the Criminal Procedure Act, 1977, differentiating between juristic person and...
Supreme Court of South Africa: While deciding upon the constitutionality of Section 7(1) (a) of the Criminal Procedure Act, 1977 insofar as allowing only private persons to institute private prosecutions and not juristic persons; and whether the differentiation is rational and connected to a legitimate governmental purpose, a 5 judge…
Foreign Courts Four month extension to the suspension on the invalidity of Sections 241(b) and 14, dealing...
Supreme Court of Canada: While deliberating upon the question that whether the Court should grant six-month extension to the suspension on the invalidity of Sections 241(b) and 14 of the Criminal Code, R.S.C. 1985, c. C-46, dealing with physician- assisted euthanasia; the 9 Judge Bench of the Court headed by…




