Justice Rajnish R. Vyas Archives

improper Interview Committee vitiates selection

Bombay HC: Selection process vitiated by improper Interview Committee; Selective relief not permissible in tainted selection

“The Committee was required to assess the performance and personality of candidates through the experienced eyes of superior officers. Therefore, delegating such powers to subordinates amounted to rewriting Government Resolution dated 23-08-2011.”

Case Briefs High Courts

Banks not bound to accept OTS offers or reveal evaluation criteria: Bombay High Court

“Such decision should be left to the commercial wisdom of the Bank whose amount is involved,and it is always to be presumed that Bank shall take a prudent decision whether to grant the benefit under the OTS scheme, having regard to the public interest involved.”

Case Briefs High Courts

‘Freedom of movement is not absolute’; Bombay HC declines interference in Western Coalfields’ order declaring ex-employee as Persona-Non-Grata

“The petitioner cannot be given free hand to visit the public offices which would certainly, affect the public administration. Even fundamental rights guaranteed under Part III of the Constitution of India are not absolute and are subjected to reasonable restrictions”.