Central Information Commission (CIC): Bimal Julka, Chief Information Commissioner, noted that the RTI application seeking very pertinent information with regard to COVID-19 pandemic was shuttled between one public authority to another and held that the Ministry of Health and Family Welfare shall collate all the information and furnish the same to complainant and on its’ website.
Complainant sought records by way of his RTI application on the following points:
- Date when the Government of India first received information on the coronavirus/Wuhan virus/ virus affecting China.
- Whether any communication was received by the Government of India about a possible pandemic like situation in India between the period of November 2019 to March, 2020?
- Copy of the minutes of meeting that took place into the possibility of declaring coronavirus a health emergency or not between the period of March 5th to March 14th, 2020.
- Whether the Government of India/any of its ministries or departments had received warnings/alerts/communication from the World Health Organisation on the possibility of coronavirus affecting India?
- Whether any internal reports on a possibility of a pandemic like situation arising in India was communicated within the Ministry or its departments?
- Any intelligence information on the coronavirus diseases originating from China possibly affecting India in future?
- Whether the Government of India/this Ministry or its various departments sought China’s assistance in getting the sample of Virus?
- Was China requested to share virus genetic sequence?
- On which date did ministry of health first communicated the information of Virus possibly affecting India to PMO?
- When was the issue of inadequate PPE discussed in the Ministry?
- Whether additional funds were sought to fight against the virus. If so the date on which the first request and subsequent requests were made and to whom be furnished?
- Whether the Ministry proposed a ban on incoming Chinese citizens to India?
- Whether the ICMR received any reports/communications/internal warnings/memos/internal reports during the period of November 2019 to March 2020 about the possibility of a pandemic like situation in India due to the virus: To this ICMR responded that all the information pertaining to circulars, notifications, etc, is available on the ICMR website.
- Whether the Government of India/this Ministry or its various departments was monitoring the situation in China and its possible effects on India?
To almost all the above queries, ICMR responded with a standard response — Not pertains to ICMR.
Complainant remained dissatisfied with the respondent’s response.
Commission observed that a voluntary disclosure of all information that ought to be displayed in the public domain should be the rule and members of public who having to seek information should be an exception.
Another significant observation was that, an open government, which is the cherished objective of the RTI Act, can be realised only if all public offices comply with proactive disclosure norms.
Several decisions are being made by the Governments involving huge interventions in the healthcare impacting daily lives of billions of people, hence it is essential that the decisions are thoroughly documented in order for the Government to remain accountable.
Information pertaining to COVID-19
Complainant sought very pertinent information with regard to COVID-19 situation, which could not be made available by the Ministry of Health and Family Welfare.
Commission held that authentic, verified and cogent reply based on factual information needs to be furnished to the complainant as also disclose on the Public Authority website for the benefit of public at large.
Secretary, Health & Family Welfare was advised to have this matter examined at an appropriate level and the Nodal Authority so notified should furnish all the details sought by the Complainant in a clear, cogent and precise manner within a period of 30 days.
In view of the above complaints were disposed of. [Saurav Das v. CPIO, 2020 SCC OnLine CIC 626, decided on 23-07-2020]