Skip to content
Latest Updates
“Legislature cannot nullify a judgment by enacting law without removing the basis”: Andhra Pradesh High Court strikes down Section 147-A, Income-tax Act, 1961 as unconstitutional ICA and RICS to host Conclave on “Mediation in Transition: Institutional Trust, Professional Standards and the Age of Artificial Intelligence” Cyril Amarchand Mangaldas advises the Placement Agents on INR 3,500 crore QIP by Aegis Logistics Limited Beyond the Code: Monil Chheda on IBC, Restructuring and Distressed Transactions Call for Papers 10.0: Faculty of Law, Maharaja Sayajirao University of Baroda invites submissions for Vox Legis Offering money, catching hold of a woman’s hand and asking her to accompany him to the jungle outrages her modesty: Himachal Pradesh High Court

‘No tax recovery can be made when GST Tribunal not constituted’; Patna HC imposes cost of Rs 5000 on GST Assessing Officer for ‘coercive’ tax recovery

“If the Appellate Tribunal under Bihar Goods and Services Tax, 2017 is constituted and an appeal is filed there can be no further proceedings taken for recovery of the balance amounts till the appeal is disposed of.”

Content reader

Listen to this article

Ready to read this article aloud.
‘No tax recovery can be made when GST Tribunal not constituted’; Patna HC imposes cost of Rs 5000 on GST Assessing Officer for ‘coercive’ tax recovery
patna high court

Patna High Court: In a case wherein, a writ petition was filed by the assessee-petitioner, National Insurance Company Limited against the order of rejection of appeal by the first Appellate Authority despite the payment of 20% of the tax in dispute for proper institution of appeal, the Division Bench of K. Vinod Chandran, CJ.,* and Rajiv Roy, J., allowed the writ petition and directed the refund of tax recovered and further, imposed a cost of Rs 5000 on the Assessing Officer who issued the demand and appropriated the money from the bank account of petitioner.

An appeal was filed by petitioner against the assessment order dated 17-02-2022 and the same was rejected. There was no Appellate Tribunal constituted as provided under Section 109 of the Bihar Goods and Services Tax Act, 2017 (‘BGST Act’). Inspite of this, petitioner paid 20% of the tax in dispute which was Rs 5.70 crores as per Section 112(8) of the Central Goods and Services Tax Act, 2017 (‘CGST Act’). When the appeal was filed, admittedly, 10% of the tax in dispute was paid, which was mandated for the institution of a proper appeal before the first Appellate Authority. Despite the payment of 20% of the tax in dispute made, the first Appellate Authority rejected the appeal, and a demand was issued. Petitioner filed the present writ petition aggrieved by the coercive action. The tax authorities in retaliation recovered the entire balance remaining payable, under Section 79 of the CGST Act.

The Court opined that if the Tribunal was constituted and an appeal was filed there could be no further proceedings taken for recovery of the balance amounts till the appeal was disposed of. Hence, when a Tribunal was not constituted, no such recovery could have been made.

The Court relied on Sita Pandey v. State of Bihar, 2023 SCC OnLine Pat 2827, and directed the refund of the entire recovered amount within two weeks and imposed a cost of Rs 5000 on the Assessing Officer, who issued the demand and appropriated the money from the bank account of petitioner. The Court further opined that petitioner should be entitled to claim interest from the department for the period in which the assessee was deprived of the amounts peremptorily recovered.

[National Insurance Co. Ltd. v. State of Bihar, 2024 SCC OnLine Pat 318, decided on 15-01-2024]

*Judgement Authored by: Chief Justice K. Vinod Chandran


Advocates who appeared in this case :

For the Petitioner: Gautam Kumar Kejriwal, Alok Kumar Jha, Mukund Kumar, Akash Kumar and Aditya Raman, Advocates

For the Respondents: Vivek Prasad, GP-7

WhatsApp LinkedIn

0 replies

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *.

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.