Skip to content
Latest Updates
“Allottee cannot be compelled to accept a belated offer of possession”: NCDRC directs builder to refund ₹1.26 crore with 9 per cent interest for delay in delivering flat in Nagpur project Post-decree deposit cannot retrospectively revive right to defend summary suit under Order 37 CPC: J&K and Ladakh HC Top Legal Developments [9-15 Nov 2026]: Digital Arrest Scams, GST, AI Deepfakes and More Law & Logic announces 1st Constitution Day Quiz Competition 2026; Registration open to law students nationwide Appreciating the scope and dimensions of “surcharge” in taxation laws: Implications of Supreme Court’s larger Bench exposition on “surcharge” and “cess” Justice Rajesh Bindal, former Supreme Court Judge assumes office as NCLAT Chairperson

Conflict between 3-judge bench decision in Rukmini case and Ram Dass case resolved

Content reader

Listen to this article

Ready to read this article aloud.
Conflict between 3-judge bench decision in Rukmini case and Ram Dass case resolved

Supreme Court: Deciding the reference made from a group of 11 appeals and 3 Special Leave Petitions to resolve the conflict between two 3-judge bench decisions i.e. Rukmini Amma Saradamma v. Kallyani Sulochana, (1993) 1 SCC 499 and Ram Dass v. Ishwar Chander, (1988) 3 SCC 131, on the question that whether the High Court, as revisional authority, under Section 15(6) of the Haryana Urban (Control of Rent & Eviction) Act, 1973 could interfere with the findings of fact of the first appellate Court/first appellate authority, the Court approved the view taken in Rukmini Case.

The present reference to a larger bench was made by the 2-judge bench as Parijat Sinha, the appellant’s counsel had relied upon the decision in Rukmini Case in support of the contention that in support of the contention that the revisional Court is not entitled to re-appreciate evidence.  However, Pravin Kumar, the respondent’s counsel had urged that the decision in Ram Dass case says that the expression “legality and propriety” enables the revisional Court to reappraise the evidence while considering the findings of the first appellate Court.

Explaining the observation in Ram Dass case that as the expression used conferring revisional jurisdiction is “legality and propriety”, the High Court has wider jurisdiction, the Court held that it obviously means that the power of revision vested in the High Court in the statute is wider than the power conferred on it under Section 115 CPC; it is not confined to the jurisdictional error alone. It was explained that the judgment does not exposit that the revisional power conferred upon the High Court is as wide as an appellate power to re-appraise or re-assess the evidence for coming to a different finding contrary to the finding recorded by the Court/Authority below, rather, it emphasises that while examining the correctness of findings of fact, the revisional Court is not the second Court of first appeal and that the decision should be read as explained by this Court.

 

The five judge bench of R.M. Lodha, CJ and Dipak Misra, Madan B. Lokur, Kurian Joseph and S.A. Bobde was of the opinion that revisional power is not and cannot be equated with the power of reconsideration of all questions of fact as a court of first appeal and that where the High Court is required to be satisfied that the decision is according to law, it may examine whether the order impugned before it suffers from procedural illegality or irregularity. Hindustan Petroleum Corporation Ltd v. Dilbahar Singh, Civil Appeal No.6177 of 2004, decided on 27.08.2014

To read the full judgment, refer SCCOnLine

WhatsApp LinkedIn

0 replies

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *.

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.